The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Sayuri-Hime]

how does this look?

i've no idea what's the ur fox going for owo

seems fine to me, the ur fox usually goes for around 1.5 nons.
both the ur mint horse and flower pot are rather hard to trade and often don't go for their full value

Is this fair?


-Starlight Owl

unfair to them, just the '10 very rare dog would be enough

Hey again guys! Sorry to be posting so much in here! I was just wondering if I could get an opinion on this trade? Thanks for all the help! trades/viewtrade.php?id=73172562&userid=158024&signature=TLmEkcXm_GBxxX-h0hcrjA

pretty unfair to you.
each store pet is worth an '10 rare or 3-4 uncommons from 2010

[Deity]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73167145&userid=754287&signature=PKKZLnWBxbDWNVdVT3PcqQ
this okay? the person is going to add 2 2015 rares OR 1 2014 rare and a another 2015 rare

This is unfair to you, their side adds up to a 2011 rare, and adding the 2 2015 rares wouldn’t make the difference between the ‘09 and their side

[Kina202]

is this fair? thanks!

vv I value 2017 store pets at 1 mid/late '10 rare
4 10' rares= from 2 09' to 1 and 1/2 '09 rares (I think) + items (I searched and one is '15 common so it's just 5 '15 commons and they don't add much) it's pretty fair!

[cloven]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73172431&userid=919435&signature=0i0qIbrGF6dDDShqpdsHQA
Is this fair?

[Zombilon]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73167145&userid=754287&signature=PKKZLnWBxbDWNVdVT3PcqQ
this okay? the person is going to add 2 2015 rares OR 1 2014 rare and a another 2015 rare

This is unfair to you, their side adds up to a 2011 rare, and adding the 2 2015 rares wouldn’t make the difference between the ‘09 and their side

Their side is actually worth a late 2010 rare + a bit more than 1/4 of another 2010 rare, so they would have to add another 2011 uncommon and two more 2010 uncommons, or remove the uncommons altogether and add a 2010 rare for this to be fair to you. The newer rares they're going to add wouldn't help the trade much at all.

[Parasoul]

I'm getting too many trades on these but like.. i need help again
Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73167714&userid=641429&signature=ryJiqLo21jVKINLxcLKb0g

[osamu]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73172710&userid=661008&signature=kbI3VERhdPZ75mHPt7Ev4Q
Is this fair rarity and demand-wise?

And this? trades/viewtrade.php?id=73172867

[Dobyeu]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73172710&userid=661008&signature=kbI3VERhdPZ75mHPt7Ev4Q%20Is%20this%20fair%20rarity%20and%20demand-wise?

wrong link send the link thats on the bottom of the trade

[Lavender Town]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73172759&userid=878073&signature=sWuf5zJIj-PEAyoAvmIgrw

This is a bid for the two of those pets and I was wondering if it's fair? Thanks.

[osamu]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73172710&userid=661008&signature=kbI3VERhdPZ75mHPt7Ev4Q%20Is%20this%20fair%20rarity%20and%20demand-wise?

wrong link send the link thats on the bottom of the trade

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73172710&userid=661008&signature=kbI3VERhdPZ75mHPt7Ev4Q

i was trying to use the URL thing but instead it put the words i added IN the link, so this should be the right one