The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Deerdancer]

Is this fair? I have been trying to get help for over a week. Involves an item for two items:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99620292&userid=203847&signature=9NtXX-_0AHE0ECIO5L_orw
and this involves two pets for a pet and some items:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=99659032&userid=203847&signature=EOcjA2UFEiKa952jTepLog

[.rat]

What do ya'll think about this trade?

Thank you <3

the 2014 pps kirin is 0.5 MA, or 3-4 09' rares. the black rainbow stripe dog has no particular demand and would be worth the 3 month rule or 2 09 rares. id say unfair to you.

[.rat]

is this trade fair?

the 2018 store pets are valued at a late 09' rare each, and their side does not add up to that, unfair to you.

[.rat]

hiya! is this fair? tysm for any help ^_^

considering the 2:1 rule (i like to use this chart) it would be fair, especially since theyre both event pets.
it's ultimately up to you as i know people prefer rares to uncommons typically no matter the year, and of course whichever you like more, lol.

[.rat]

Hello!
I believe this (click!) is fair, but wanted to check/get a second opinion
Thank you!

i like to use this chart for comparing uncommons and rares from different years and the 2:1 rule.
overall the trade is in your favor since a 2011 uncommon would equal a 2013 rare, even though rares are more sought after i think the add ons make it fair :)

[.rat]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99752020&userid=1025686&signature=AlzTC1gKUbGeS1ddtzEBDA


How fair is this? I know my side has a higher demand

the teal butterbun is a t8 advent worth about 1 MA.
the firestar warrior cat is worth about 1 MA as well.
its fair, but its up to you how you value the warrior cats because their demand is pretty significant.

[squarshed]

Hello! I don't know c$ values that well, so is this a fair trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99755452&userid=812055&signature=p6Vphkd9GF4Gr-xIH_SM4g

[.rat]

Hello! I don't know c$ values that well, so is this a fair trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99755452&userid=812055&signature=p6Vphkd9GF4Gr-xIH_SM4g

the 2018 bwolf store pets seem to be valued at around 50 c$, and im not aware of any particular demand so i believe this is fair :)

[squarshed]

Okay, thank you so much! I just got another trade in, does anyone know if this looks fair? I'm not sure of the spider b-wolf's value in comparison

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99617233&userid=812055&signature=jZYA9Mmn20XHU8Onvg6khA

[.rat]

Is this a fair swap?

theres no particular demand for either, but the malachite pps turned VR march 2016 and the green swirl colors turned vr jan 2019. since the green swirl is an early 09 rare and the pps is a late 09 rare, i think it evens out imo, but its up to you :)