The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Bingus]

Not really sure what animal eggs go for, so thoughts on this one?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93202781&userid=356938&signature=mw9yp5zAGLh2IWXUvdhobA

i would decline as people would give more than just that for the animal eggs

[~Sunlight~]

Is this fair??
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93199848&userid=961232&signature=1wnCqsikqT2z21sFypLSWQ

Any ideas? Any help is appreciated!

I would hate to keep them waiting..

[venti]

thank you to the person who gave me advice on my last trade.
im puzzled on this new one especially with the jumping years, is this fair? if not, whos overpaying? any advice?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93202205&userid=731952&signature=DolZ3WW6T46ugaN5HoyF1w

my opinion:
their side is overpaying ; i go by the common + common = uncommon and so on.
their side is worth a 2012 rare, whilst yours is just a 2019 very rare (not including the commons/uncommon on either side)
please get a second opinion ^^

Not really sure what animal eggs go for, so thoughts on this one?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93202781&userid=356938&signature=mw9yp5zAGLh2IWXUvdhobA

i would decline as people would give more than just that for the animal eggs

do not give false advice, people may overpay for animal eggs but i highly disagree.
animal eggs tend to go for an uncommon of their release date (e.g a 2019 animal egg = 1 2019 uncommon.)

[Diaval]

Not really sure what animal eggs go for, so thoughts on this one?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93202781&userid=356938&signature=mw9yp5zAGLh2IWXUvdhobA

i would decline as people would give more than just that for the animal eggs

Thank you! I would love a second opinion just to be sure

[Midnight_Shadow18450]

Can I have a verdict on this please? They sent it to me

trades/viewtrade.php?id=93186014&userid=42224&signature=B1QkL0bzAh1GYoH-bE1VCw

[Amplify]

Hello! Would this be a fair trade?

[Cøpacetic]

Does the mutant really trade for an MA? I feel like everywhere I read says 4-5 09 rares but nobody will take my trade.
I’ve been offering a rare 09 malk cat, rare 09 malk fish, and two rare 09 sitting cats (not warriors)

[Lord Ghirahim]

Is this fair??
trades/viewtrade.php?id=93199848&userid=961232&signature=1wnCqsikqT2z21sFypLSWQ

None of those pets have any special demand (as far as I know) therefore, it's mainly a choice of preference. Considering, though, that one side has a 2015 uncommon, among other pets, and the other side only has 2020 commons, I'd say it was very unfair.

3 month rule, plus the need to match rarities. But if you value the staff pets more, it's up to you!

[.crossfire.]

[quote="Cøpacetic"]Does the mutant really trade for an MA? I feel like everywhere I read says 4-5 09 rares but nobody will take my trade.
I’ve been offering a rare 09 malk cat, rare 09 malk fish, and two rare 09 sitting cats (not warriors)[/quote]
[center][size=85]the mutant is technically worth the three month rule, however it has traded for an MA+ but everyone values the pet differently.[/size][/center]

[Cøpacetic]

Does the mutant really trade for an MA? I feel like everywhere I read says 4-5 09 rares but nobody will take my trade.
I’ve been offering a rare 09 malk cat, rare 09 malk fish, and two rare 09 sitting cats (not warriors)

the mutant is technically worth the three month rule, however it has traded for an MA+ but everyone values the pet differently.

Do you think if I’m patient somebody will take my offer? I’d assume the pets I’m offering have pretty good demand too