The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[snowdrake]

Help me please!
Is this fair?
I know it's October 2008 re-release, so it looks suspiciously good XD
Are elements Malks that worthy?

it depends on how you value the elemental malk cats. they are very popular and get a pretty good amount of overpay. this is already overpay rarity-wise, but demand depends on you. I personally wouldn't accept it, but it's not a bad offer.

[Kabuski]

ur foal for 1,240 c$

i could be wrong but last time i checked, the
UR foal; without demand is around 1190c$, get another
opinion though! (I'm not sure of its worth with demand haha)

I guess 2nd opinion then LOL

[Biparo]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89552988&userid=13352&signature=1UegFmBDi4WXRskVE4pB4w

This feels a tad unfair to me, can someone help?

[venti]

]Smells new thread
How's this?
+
x[/qu
no one has helped me. I've been asking

>:

[Viridian Dragonkoi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89074275&userid=127999&signature=Eqv62qVtmy0Hdssp5woZWg

Please and thank you!

over to you, grinner is 1.5-2 ma's, i counted 15 09 rares worth with just the rats and 09 dogs, the rats together is 9 09 rares if someone is looking for them, the dogs are 2 09 rares each, so that alone is over for the grinner, adding the store pets is 4 09s worth. a Ma is 7-8 09s but bulk is high demand and i personally think you could get better.

Thank you.

Second opinion anyone please?

[DisneyLuv]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89552988&userid=13352&signature=1UegFmBDi4WXRskVE4pB4w

This feels a tad unfair to me, can someone help?

The other user doesn’t seem to know how store pets are valued, which is likely why there’s confusion. Each of their stores pets, aside from the 2018 one, are worth an ‘09 rare with the 2018 being worth just one ‘10 rare. They are valuing them too high. One of the ‘09 VR’s, plus an ‘09 rare and a ‘10 rare would be a fair swap for their pets. Anything is else is extreme overpay that they’re expecting from you.

[Lexi.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89552541&userid=919527&signature=PpW82OdH1Er6C6ZinSoApA
Ive heard the set goes for a non, but how about demand? Would this be fair?

If you're valuing the set at 1 non, the rainbow horse would be fair for the set. It's over on their part.

They're asking for 7 extra warriors along with the set. Not sure what the rbm goes for with demand

[DisneyLuv]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=89074275&userid=127999&signature=Eqv62qVtmy0Hdssp5woZWg

Please and thank you!

over to you, grinner is 1.5-2 ma's, i counted 15 09 rares worth with just the rats and 09 dogs, the rats together is 9 09 rares if someone is looking for them, the dogs are 2 09 rares each, so that alone is over for the grinner, adding the store pets is 4 09s worth. a Ma is 7-8 09s but bulk is high demand and i personally think you could get better.

Grinners are 1.25 MA’s at max value. They’re asking for major overpay. 1.25 MA’s is approximately 9 ‘09 rares. That would be a fair value for the grinner. You have 3 MA’s worth on your side in total, and sometimes the 2017 stores can go for overpay. Definitely definitely unfair to you.

[Biparo]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=89552988&userid=13352&signature=1UegFmBDi4WXRskVE4pB4w

This feels a tad unfair to me, can someone help?

The other user doesn’t seem to know how store pets are valued, which is likely why there’s confusion. Each of their stores pets, aside from the 2018 one, are worth an ‘09 rare with the 2018 being worth just one ‘10 rare. They are valuing them too high. One of the ‘09 VR’s, plus an ‘09 rare and a ‘10 rare would be a fair swap for their pets. Anything is else is extreme overpay that they’re expecting from you.

Thanks a ton!

[aniuk]

hello! i just received this trade for my coontail. (nonjewel and blue sorb)

from what i've read, coontails are worth 1.5-2 nons but more commonly get 1.5. that being said, would it be better for me to stick with the coontail or trade it off?

any opinions appreciated, thank you for the help x