[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[SeaCrest]

Im really conflicted about this trade and I need help haha. So the green Alien dog is a dreamie of mine but I'd really like to trade my Angry basilisk for a Shy Basilisk so idk. I would like to know if rarity wise this trade is fair! trades/viewtrade.php?id=85102895&userid=674298&signature=vXzREWd-OLN8UQzJwVnQUA

The basilisk set is are tier 2 advents, which according to the old gaps list at the time the list was retired were worth 4-5 mixed 2009 rares. The green alien dog is a tier 1 advent, worth 3-4 mixed 2009 rares. With the added Tan Ear Wood Dog (which is not a list pet) worth 2 2009 rares, the offer comes to 5-6 mixed 2009 rares, which would be overpay. Please get a second opinion, as I don't know what the current list market looks like!

[♥Princess of Lions♥]

I need some opinions on the following trades please and thank you!!

Trade #1
Trade #2
Trade #3
Trade #4

Thank you so much to anyone who helps me out!!

[Falkenfire]

Is this fair? I don't know if the owl still has good demand. Thank you!

[Gravejunky]

Can someone help me with this trade? / is it fair?

Thanks ahead of time for the help!

[Angelhearth]

Is this fair?
Click me!

[uro]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85104056&userid=741998&signature=wUYjsqEqDYF3ki3bQkbNNA

help?

[WellWell]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85098406&userid=892678&signature=LsbFCquppzPMfwJX9HLBAQ
Fair? ^^

[dovepool_]

I’d really like to keeps these babies, but like I dunno. The rat and the tokens don’t look at all appealing to me but I’m just not sure
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85104388&userid=974598&signature=XNNHWcH_R_jjHywuiyX16w

[Aurora Storm]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85104056&userid=741998&signature=wUYjsqEqDYF3ki3bQkbNNA

help?

Unfair to you. Your rat alone is worth more than the guinea pig, or even just the two '10 rares together would be enough.

Can someone help me with this trade? / is it fair?

Thanks ahead of time for the help!

Wrong link, we need the one at the bottom of the page c:

I’d really like to keeps these babies, but like I dunno. The rat and the tokens don’t look at all appealing to me but I’m just not sure
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85104388&userid=974598&signature=XNNHWcH_R_jjHywuiyX16w

Personal preference plays a huge part in trading, so if you don't find their offer appealing I wouldn't take it, even if it is fair. Which it's still unfair to you regardless, the 2018 store pets are worth a mid 2010 rare each and their's are all advents.

[Angelhearth]

Is this fair?
Click me!