The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[ScuroFenice]

Is this fair? Also if it's not how should I edit it?

unfair to you I'd say, the horse is an '09 rare and the earliest pet they've offered is an early 2010 uncommon, maybe have them add a mid or early 2010 rare? get another answer from someone else as I don't know if my opinion is accurate or not, lol

I've had two unfair to me offers from this person. Here is my current offer to them http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20431646&userid=20172&signature=NyhMqi4IY6PnJB0x3sFajA Is this fair at all? What would be fair in terms of '10 uncommons and rares and '09 uncommons

Each of the bunnies is worth a mid 2010 rare; unfair to them as most of the pets are late commons or uncommons; ask another opinion before deciding anything, I'm still learning myself

[Ansim]

I just got this awesome trade, but I was wondering how fair it is to both of us?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D-w7pCxrsg
And what about demand wise? c:

Also:
Target dog + Purple toxic + Yellow sorbet = CEG and BEG? Is this fair?

Trade: i believe it's unfair to them. From what i know, the non dogs are woth 3 sorbets.

The question: I think it's unfair to the BEG and CEG but you should ask for a second opinion

Have a nice day

[Quitting~]

Fiar for '11 halloween PPS dog? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QOTh5ykGDA

[Ancient Fairy Dragon]

Is this fair? Also if it's not how should I edit it?

unfair to you I'd say, the horse is an '09 rare and the earliest pet they've offered is an early 2010 uncommon, maybe have them add a mid or early 2010 rare? get another answer from someone else as I don't know if my opinion is accurate or not, lol

Thank you C:

[ScuroFenice]

Also:
Target dog + Purple toxic + Yellow sorbet = CEG and BEG? Is this fair?

The question: I think it's unfair to the BEG and CEG but you should ask for a second opinion

Have a nice day

I agree with ansem on this, the BEG is one tier above the purple toxic and the target dog isn't even in the main rares list; it's in the September advents; so even though the toxic is also a tier above the CEG I would say unfair to the galaxy dogs

[Ansim]

Hi!
May i ask if this is fair rarity and demand wise, please?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eNl3nZe0hA

Thanks and have a nice day

[GreatWhiteDragon_1]

I've had two unfair to me offers from this person. Here is my current offer to them http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20431646&userid=20172&signature=NyhMqi4IY6PnJB0x3sFajA Is this fair at all? What would be fair in terms of '10 uncommons and rares and '09 uncommons

Very unfair to the store pets. Each pet, by itself, is worth a Rare 2 years before. Together they can get a late '09 Rare.

[the force awakens.]

Would this be fair?

Just making sure.

[ScuroFenice]

how fair is this? i don't know the worth of the '08 cat (Cloudtail) and was wondering which side is unfair if it is and what needs to be added

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20432228&userid=247513&signature=R7KfefnFp8QB_u_phLKg7g

[Fat Unicorn]

Would this be fair?

Just making sure.

Unfair to them. ^^