The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SmittenDragonKitten]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78298541&userid=945336&signature=RUgX2BVS1f1bkFX033iZwg

Do you guys think this is fair?

or this? trades/viewtrade.php?id=78298505&userid=945336&signature=v3doyZUjmD5OgM-hl3HQsQ

[miyoni]

is this fair?

[soobin]

Is this fair to me demand wise? Looks tempting...

[spencer]

whaddya think about this one?

need a reply quickly. it's for my auction and i don't know if accepting it would be a good idea or could i get better offers? ;0

thanks in advance!

edit;
how about this one as well? thanks!

Well since the cat has no set value yet, everything is entirely up to you. The first one is decent, not so much demand wise though.
The second depends on if you like the Aussie

ahh im really in love with the warriors, but is the possible purple toxic worth them? also, what is the demand for toxics in general? thanks!! trades/viewtrade.php?id=78298381&userid=786862&signature=eB6XeUZJjaiA_VjIRsxHRw

The Warriors aren't worth a toxic, so it's highly unfair to you. Depends on if you really love them as much as to give a toxic.

HELP
I REALLY need help here! I love the blue malk and I know the marionette demand is like, ALL over the place.
As a small example as to what was gotten (not much help with multiple pets, I know); xXx
Edit: They (obviously won't say user for privacy reasons) also said that it could be edited to the liking

I've already answered this, I said I'd take it. They're overpaying, so it depends on which pet you like more.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78298541&userid=945336&signature=RUgX2BVS1f1bkFX033iZwg

Do you guys think this is fair?

or this? trades/viewtrade.php?id=78298505&userid=945336&signature=v3doyZUjmD5OgM-hl3HQsQ

1) very unfair to you
2) slightly unfair to them, the rat has terrible demand though

is this fair?

Very unfair to them, the phoenix is worth 1 non and 1 sorbet and the cat will likely not be worth 3 nons

[TooSpooky]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78298744&userid=875569&signature=gUP84jVVpKJP3yTZXYCh6g

Would this be fair?? Thanks for any help

[Spyraoverlord]

Is this a fair trade?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78242088&userid=126728&signature=ezLqJIJ6cB6zN8qU9YqnBw

[spencer]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78298744&userid=875569&signature=gUP84jVVpKJP3yTZXYCh6g

Would this be fair?? Thanks for any help

Unfair to you. The cat will very likely not be placed as high as the UR Bwolf

[TooSpooky]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78298744&userid=875569&signature=gUP84jVVpKJP3yTZXYCh6g

Would this be fair?? Thanks for any help

Unfair to you. The cat will very likely not be placed as high as the UR Bwolf

Thanks very much, again

[choerry]

ahh im really in love with the warriors, but is the possible purple toxic worth them? also, what is the demand for toxics in general? thanks!! trades/viewtrade.php?id=78298381&userid=786862&signature=eB6XeUZJjaiA_VjIRsxHRw

The Warriors aren't worth a toxic, so it's highly unfair to you. Depends on if you really love them as much as to give a toxic.

thank you ^^

could i have another opinion including demand and personal opinions; would you accept this yourself?

[lyriclover]

ahh im really in love with the warriors, but is the possible purple toxic worth them? also, what is the demand for toxics in general? thanks!! trades/viewtrade.php?id=78298381&userid=786862&signature=eB6XeUZJjaiA_VjIRsxHRw

The Warriors aren't worth a toxic, so it's highly unfair to you. Depends on if you really love them as much as to give a toxic.

thank you ^^

could i have another opinion including demand?

Agreed highly unfair to the toxic