The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[nice]

Could somebody please tell me whether they think this is fair or not? Thank you!

Unfair to you I believe c:

[Julia]

Fair? Would you go for that?

demand says unfair to you, but i don't know about rarity *shrug*
rats aren't exactly my area of expertise

Its unfair to them (the rat is the the rares list, forth line up) It would be hard to trade off and is worth less than normal, but not that much less.

Well, well, thank you both for your opinion, but just one reply; would you accept that? I knew (at least thought so) that it's unfair to them, but I'm not too fond of a pet which isn't getting me anything. - And warriors are in quite demand. Difficult decision, really. Usually I'd accepted it right away.

[Creature Feature <3]

Would this be fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19399707&userid=210218&signature=V87mGsPE6mlg36X6qR1kFg Sorry canceled, what about this one? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... A9lcwGa1Pg
Thanks.

[scorps]

Fair? Would you go for that?

demand says unfair to you, but i don't know about rarity *shrug*
rats aren't exactly my area of expertise

Its unfair to them (the rat is the the rares list, forth line up) It would be hard to trade off and is worth less than normal, but not that much less.

Well, well, thank you both for your opinion, but just one reply; would you accept that? I knew (at least thought so) that it's unfair to them, but I'm not too fond of a pet which isn't getting me anything. - And warriors are in quite demand. Difficult decision, really. Usually I'd accepted it right away.

Personally, i wouldn't accept that because i don't think i could get much from it :3
But again, that's just me personally since you asked c:

[Trexxa]

Could somebody please tell me whether they think this is fair or not? Thank you!

Unfair to you I believe c:

I agree, you're overpaying just a little bit, but not much.

[From the Stars]

Hello, I was wondering whether this trade is fair to me? The Blood PPS is one down from the dark leopard, rares-list-wise, but are the GUPPS and the August Lion enough to fill the gap? ^^
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=19399727
Thank you very much.

[Creature Feature <3]

We can't view the trade From the Stars.

[fifetastic]

I'm thinking this is pretty fair, but just wanted to double check
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19399380&userid=46909&signature=JnCaO-D-MW6QQf-tD6TPbw

[HSoup]

Help anyone ?
I feel like its not quite enough for the 2008 re-release, but I am not sure

[scorps]

I'm thinking this is pretty fair, but just wanted to double check
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=19399380&userid=46909&signature=JnCaO-D-MW6QQf-tD6TPbw

I believe that is slightly unfair to you, but only because your dog has better demand c: