The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Quackers <3]

Line Tribal+ Nick Cake Dog = Blue Toxic???

That would be very unfair to the blue toxic, which is several tiers above the line tribal. The nick cake dog is only an advent and not enough to fill the gap according to the gaps list. I'm afraid I don't know what would need to be added.

The nick cake dog is a sept. List

Please don't give false advice, the Nick Cake Dog is a tier 5 Advent.

The side with the line tribal + NCD would need to add the worth of approximately 51 Mid Advents OR A Green Toxic + A Dark Leopard.
Please get a second opinion as I am a bit rusty with main list trades.

[pink]

The nick cake dog is a sept. List

Please look through the rares list again. It is a tier 5 advent. It is not included with the other cake dogs. I don't mean to be rude but I would advise you to learn a bit more about the rares list as newer player before giving advise. There is a lot to learn and a lot that you might miss.

I agree, I'm sorry to add into this but I have seen you giving false advice to people ClashWithCringe, you really should not be telling/helping people with trades until you know the rarity system well. It could cause a person to accept a bad trade. Here is a list DaDwarf made with all the main lists, sept lists and advent lists on it in order of their rarity; viewtopic.php?t=112366

[CRINGE!!]

The nick cake dog is a sept. List

Please look through the rares list again. It is a tier 5 advent. It is not included with the other cake dogs. I don't mean to be rude but I would advise you to learn a bit more about the rares list as newer player before giving advise. There is a lot to learn and a lot that you might miss. I would hate for you to unknowingly give someone false advise about a trade. Thank you.

Don't worry, you were not being rude! Sorry bout that, I continue to get those few mixed up. They are very similar.

[elio.]

Is the flower pot a swap for cinnabun?(1) If not what would be added?
And what about this?(2)
And what about this trade?(3) but instead of Aussie the ur lion?
Thank you in advance!! <3

[LO$ER=LO♡ER]

hello, could I get an opinion on this? I know the Gemini zodiac (or any zodiac) has got a lot of demand, would this be fair?

[Pelicandreams]

I'm having an auction for my animal egg 3.

I'm not the best at item auctions, so I would appreciate any advice that you can give:
This bid has some valuable items, but again, I'm not fantastic at item values
This bid has great items in quantity, and some pets
This bid has two advents

I am not sure which of these bids is fair, and I don't want to trade my item for less than it is worth so which of these trade are fair? Or are they all fair? Thanks!

[Benzene]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63456416&userid=4766&signature=SxSQdg7J72Oyd7IdgsrFLA
how's this for my shima? is it fair demand wise? thanks!!

Get a second opinion, but personally I think they are overpaying. The shima is originally a staff pet from '09 so it would be worth a regular '09 rare, but due to its demand, its more.

*This is What I have been told (below) so if it's wrong, I'm sorry*
I have been told by multiple people that the shima demand is starting to drop, so it's not worth as much as it used to be.

thank you! a second opinion would be great! ^^

[LO$ER=LO♡ER]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63456416&userid=4766&signature=SxSQdg7J72Oyd7IdgsrFLA
how's this for my shima? is it fair demand wise? thanks!!

Get a second opinion, but personally I think they are overpaying. The shima is originally a staff pet from '09 so it would be worth a regular '09 rare, but due to its demand, its more.

*This is What I have been told (below) so if it's wrong, I'm sorry*
I have been told by multiple people that the shima demand is starting to drop, so it's not worth as much as it used to be.

honestly, I would say they are overpaying. as someone else already said, its a 2009 rare, so it would be WORTH a 2009 rare if it didn't have a lot of demand. there are also a lot of store pets in that trade, and a '09 staff birthday sitting cat, even a zodiac. I hope this helped in any way, sorry if I am wrong.

[Fwutter]

Is the flower pot a swap for cinnabun?(1) If not what would be added?
And what about this?(2)
And what about this trade?(3) but instead of Aussie the ur lion?
Thank you in advance!! <3

Alright, so the cinnabun is going for about a non right now, so lets keep that in mind for the following trades :>

1. Unfair to the top rarity wise, the UR flowerpot is worth 1-2 nons (i was told the UR holy goes for 2, since they are the same tier i think thats what the flower goes for rarity wise :>), but demand wise, I would definitely not take this. I've never seen the UR flower go for a non. I've very rarely see th UR flower go for its actual worth. So I wouldn't accept this if I where you because demand plays a big role in this trade.

2. Rarity wise they are still overpaying as said in the first response. Demand wise, this still doesn't really add up to a non demand wise, so personally I wouldn't accept.

3. Rarity wise, they are overpaying, the UR aussie ((and the UR lion) is above the nons tier, valuing it at about 2-3 nons(?), I don't think the green toxic is worth 1-2 non(s). Demand wise, I haven't ever really seen the aussie go for a non, I highly suggest another opinion on the third trade.

[Scrump]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dWvuWqdjdA

Can I have someone's opinion on this? thank you