The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Benzene]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d7IdgsrFLA
how's this for my shima? is it fair demand wise? thanks!!

[The Last Raven]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7c5v_bnfiA

Unfair to them. Only their two '09 rares would be enough for the '09 very rare. c:

Actually that isn't true. The bwolf is a tier one list pet and is therefore worth 3-4 09 rares.

[Hauntednightmares]

Should I take omgsr bwolf for my coontail? Which is easier to trade off

[CRINGE!!]

Should I take omgsr bwolf for my coontail? Which is easier to trade off

I would in an instant

[Fwutter]

Should I take omgsr bwolf for my coontail? Which is easier to trade off

I would in an instant

Please try to give detailed advice.
This is unfair rarity wise, but demand wise, I personally think the coontail is easier to trade off than the UR butterfly wolf. The UR bwolf takes a longer wait to find someone willing to overpay or trade fairly for.

[pink]

Should I take omgsr bwolf for my coontail? Which is easier to trade off

I would in an instant

I disagree, Coontails have a better demand than an OMGSR Butterfly Wolf. Though the Coontail is a bit lower on the list than a OMGSR Butterfly wolf I still find it unfair due to the higher demand the Coontail has.

[Jiloon]

Should I take omgsr bwolf for my coontail? Which is easier to trade off

I would in an instant

Please explain your answer c: Also, seeing as you joined within the last 48 hours, perhaps you should wait to give advice until you've been on the site for a while?

I think the bwolf is easier to trade off for higher value since it's very high up on the List. However, it has a little worse demand than the Coontail, though both are difficult to trade off. I would take the bwolf only because it's so much higher up, but with the understanding that getting two Nons for either pet takes patience and time.

[CRINGE!!]

Should I take omgsr bwolf for my coontail? Which is easier to trade off

I would in an instant

Please explain your answer c: Also, seeing as you joined within the last 48 hours, perhaps you should wait to give advice until you've been on the site for a while?

I think the bwolf is easier to trade off for higher value since it's very high up on the List. However, it has a little worse demand than the Coontail, though both are difficult to trade off. I would take the bwolf only because it's so much higher up, but with the understanding that getting two Nons for either pet takes patience and time.

Jilloon Please worry about yourself! I know the list, and I have been well educated on it by my friends. There is no reason why you should be intervening!

[.crossfire.]

@Clash, take off topic things to pm. And Hilton was not interfering. They were giving a suggestion. Don't take any offense. If you have a problem with them, pm them]]

Line Gearback+Nick Cake Dog = Toxic?

[RiN_X04]

I would in an instant

Please explain your answer c: Also, seeing as you joined within the last 48 hours, perhaps you should wait to give advice until you've been on the site for a while?

I think the bwolf is easier to trade off for higher value since it's very high up on the List. However, it has a little worse demand than the Coontail, though both are difficult to trade off. I would take the bwolf only because it's so much higher up, but with the understanding that getting two Nons for either pet takes patience and time.

Jilloon Please worry about yourself! I know the list, and I have been well educated on it by my friends. There is no reason why you should be intervening!

Technically, there is, since this is a thread for giving advice, and sometimes that advice can make or break a trade. No one wants to accept an unfair trade.