The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ILoveYou3000]

Is this fair? Hosting an auction and it's a bid
trades/viewtrade.php?id=96127957&userid=976801&signature=Zxy58QV-5ZNp1qezclfeBg

Also is this fair? Another bid.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=96133453&userid=976801&signature=R7fdw3rv1q36mX98pPxRvA

Got another bid, how about this one
trades/viewtrade.php?id=96137434&userid=976801&signature=DD2cl0AP-__T8k5hDlK4Fg

[Sprudel]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96136608&userid=198071&signature=upDMA9txh7EiKBNtDSZNug

is this a fair trade?

[Cady55again]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96136608&userid=198071&signature=upDMA9txh7EiKBNtDSZNug

is this a fair trade?

edit: just saw it was a re-release so now I'm even more confused aaaaa

[mitts]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96136608&userid=198071&signature=upDMA9txh7EiKBNtDSZNug

is this a fair trade?

I'm not good with trades above a rare but even I can see that's super unfair, they're asking for TWO very rares for one that's not as old as the ones offered. That's not fair to you

please don’t give false advice. the rare on their side is a rerelease, and is more valuable than its date suggests.

please do get a second opinion (i’m on mobile so i cant search for data), but this may be unfair to them. their pet is worth 7-9 ‘09 rares (it’s a midadvent), and i believe your side is worth 6?

[Vampirism.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96137001&userid=871576&signature=BFgRDP8_N8iCDLle0embHQ help?

[Deoledath]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96136608&userid=198071&signature=upDMA9txh7EiKBNtDSZNug

is this a fair trade?

I'm not good with trades above a rare but even I can see that's super unfair, they're asking for TWO very rares for one that's not as old as the ones offered. That's not fair to you

please don’t give false advice. the rare on their side is a rerelease, and is more valuable than its date suggests.

please do get a second opinion (i’m on mobile so i cant search for data), but this may be unfair to them. their pet is worth 7-9 ‘09 rares (it’s a midadvent), and i believe your side is worth 6?

The rerelease dog is an MA rerelease from 2008 -- the wolf is a low october and. The Low October is rated at about 0.5 MA -- the total worth of the MA is 6-9 '09 rares so I would say slightly unfair to them (however, as I am new I would reconfirm with someone else that my math is correct since the one pet is a store pet I believe)

[LavenderHaze]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96136608&userid=198071&signature=upDMA9txh7EiKBNtDSZNug

is this a fair trade?

I'm not good with trades above a rare but even I can see that's super unfair, they're asking for TWO very rares for one that's not as old as the ones offered. That's not fair to you

please don’t give false advice. the rare on their side is a rerelease, and is more valuable than its date suggests.

please do get a second opinion (i’m on mobile so i cant search for data), but this may be unfair to them. their pet is worth 7-9 ‘09 rares (it’s a midadvent), and i believe your side is worth 6?

The rerelease dog is an MA rerelease from 2008 -- the wolf is a low october and. The Low October is rated at about 0.5 MA -- the total worth of the MA is 6-9 '09 rares so I would say slightly unfair to them (however, as I am new I would reconfirm with someone else that my math is correct since the one pet is a store pet I believe)

The store pet is worth 2 09 rares so their side comes out to about 5 09 rares . For it to be fair you would need to add ~ 2-3 09 rares IMO.

[ghoulette]

Any thoughts? (Keeping demand and such in mind)
(Click)
Thank you very much!

[angelberry]

how is this trade? : )

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96139138&userid=121954&signature=cr1UXwT9p7Rf2J96H7DQ2w

[cassiopeiaa]

Help? trades/viewtrade.php?id=96120438&userid=829466&signature=g6t8q_EtEPI30eK17xLKnQ

help please?