The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[pink]

What do you guys thing about this trade?

This is an extreme overpay on their side since the cat they are offering is the UR ice cat, it doesn't have the best demand but this is way over on their side since your side only comes up to a tier 1 or 2 list pet (since the dragon has such a high demand.)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63406198&userid=21052&signature=Igsfk8S6ccFic4ZmiEIOCg

I want to know if this was fair to me?

As an item collector I would say this is very unfair on your side since most of the items are older and are never re-released.

[Fwutter]

What do you guys thing about this trade?

Oh they are massively overtrading!!!!! The UR ice cat usually goes for the underpay, but not THAT much underpay!!!!

[Hauntednightmares]

What do you guys thing about this trade?

HOLY OVER. The ice cat is a huge Mainlist and worth alot more then the pets they want

[The Last Raven]

fair?

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think that 2010 uncommon is a warrior cat. Saying that this is unfair to you, a 2013 store pet is only worth a 2009 rare, the extra '10 UC and items makes the trade slightly unfair to you. Corgi's usually do go for overpay, but it's up to how you value the corgi store pets.

Thank you, I know the other corgis (natural) have a lot of demand but I wasn't sure about this one.


To those who keep telling me why I am asking since I give advice all the time, sometimes I need advice too especially if it is a pet that I don't keep up with much. I get to ask like everyone else^^

[Fwutter]

fair?

Ok come on! I see you GIVING advice always! This is any easy one!! Your overpaying a lot

Just because a specific person gives out a lot of advice, doesn't mean they too can be unsure about a trade. Please don't pressure them about not knowing if a trade is fair or not.

[NineTail]

fair?

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think that 2010 uncommon is a warrior cat. Saying that this is unfair to you, a 2013 store pet is only worth a 2009 rare, the extra '10 UC and items makes the trade slightly unfair to you. Corgi's usually do go for overpay, but it's up to how you value the corgi store pets.

Thank you, I know the other corgis (natural) have a lot of demand but I wasn't sure about this one.


To those who keep telling me why I am asking since I give advice all the time, sometimes I need advice too especially if it is a pet that I don't keep up with much. I get to ask like everyone else^^

Sorry if you felt that way, I didn't want to be rude!

[sakk_12]

What do you guys thing about this trade?

This is an extreme overpay on their side since the cat they are offering is the UR ice cat, it doesn't have the best demand but this is way over on their side since your side only comes up to a tier 1 or 2 list pet (since the dragon has such a high demand.)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63406198&userid=21052&signature=Igsfk8S6ccFic4ZmiEIOCg

I want to know if this was fair to me?

As an item collector I would say this is very unfair on your side since most of the items are older and are never re-released.

thanks, *sigh*

[Hauntednightmares]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63452651&userid=867096&signature=yomZIyfoOXIa1dqIcLjgCg

If you were me. Would you accept?
Generally speaking July has worse demand, but I wanna see what other people think. And does July USUALLY go for 2 nons?

[SChapton]

Is this fair for my rose dog
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UJRiBppcug

[Pelicandreams]

I'm having an auction for my animal egg 3.

I'm not the best at item auctions, so I would appreciate any advice that you can give:
This bid has some valuable items, but again, I'm not fantastic at item values
This bid has great items in quantity, and some pets
This bid has two advents

I am not sure which of these bids is fair, and I don't want to trade my item for less than it is worth so which of these trade are fair? Or are they all fair? Thanks!