The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[StardewAddict]

aannnd just got this trade lol
trades/viewtrade.php?id=96135583&userid=657426&signature=s6XcBNR5TyFQbPOuif32Zw

Is this fair ?

[MissDream]

Hi! I don't know about items, are fair? I don't know if items are old or rare

1- trades/viewtrade.php?id=96134519&userid=587322&signature=IxNBNx-gObM0qV0Ojv6yQQ
2 - trades/viewtrade.php?id=96134518&userid=587322&signature=lkI6RAx-xKYS8MmuzSEwzg
3- trades/viewtrade.php?id=96127921&userid=587322&signature=635eX0ItAQStQIATrGY_qw
4 - trades/viewtrade.php?id=96127919&userid=587322&signature=orEwPwhp0NLzsCTJ6GdypQ
5 - trades/viewtrade.php?id=96127121&userid=587322&signature=Av8W8u6peC8vjBg-a5nGbw

[mitts]

aannnd just got this trade lol
trades/viewtrade.php?id=96135583&userid=657426&signature=s6XcBNR5TyFQbPOuif32Zw

Is this fair ?

i believe this is unfair to them? their side is worth about 4.5 09 vrs, and unless your pet has some special demand that im not aware of, yours is only worth 1
personally, i wouldnt accept this trade anyway as horses and rats can be pretty hard to trade, but thats just an opinion

[Sali]

Please help c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96135002&userid=273533&signature=Wa9zruLlVUY-JEgJFbK_zQ

[mitts]

Please help c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96135002&userid=273533&signature=Wa9zruLlVUY-JEgJFbK_zQ

skelebun is worth 10-20 nons, but mostly trades for the 12-15 range

eat me: 4-5 n
drink me: 6 n
punk dogs (excl. lolita): 1.5n
lolita: 1-1.5n

this one,, really depends on how you value your pets,, and i would def get a second opinion

[saküra]

Please help c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96135002&userid=273533&signature=Wa9zruLlVUY-JEgJFbK_zQ

skelebun is worth 10-20 nons, but mostly trades for the 12-15 range

eat me: 4-5 n
drink me: 6 n
punk dogs (excl. lolita): 1.5n
lolita: 1-1.5n

this one,, really depends on how you value your pets,, and i would def get a second opinion

i agree with them but then again it’s SO hard to trade off something worth so much for bulk list pets and it’d be a lot easier to trade off your pets so i would keep your side but it’s whatever you’d like to do. it’s just hard to trade the skelebun down for a good variety of pets

[Guest]

Please help c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96135002&userid=273533&signature=Wa9zruLlVUY-JEgJFbK_zQ

honestly, I feel as though skelebun would difficult to trade away as not many people have enough fodder to trade for it. its quite expensive for what it is so its really up to whether you want to keep your quantity or if you'd prefer quality. in the past it has traded for over 15n. if you plan on keeping it, I think this is a nice offer! but again, finding the right person who would trade 15n+ for it in good pets may take some time. there are a few skelebuns in circulation atm and the people who own them seem to have had them for awhile

[MissDream]

Hi! I don't know about items, are fair? I don't know if items are old or rare

1- trades/viewtrade.php?id=96134519&userid=587322&signature=IxNBNx-gObM0qV0Ojv6yQQ
2 - trades/viewtrade.php?id=96134518&userid=587322&signature=lkI6RAx-xKYS8MmuzSEwzg
3- trades/viewtrade.php?id=96127921&userid=587322&signature=635eX0ItAQStQIATrGY_qw
4 - trades/viewtrade.php?id=96127919&userid=587322&signature=orEwPwhp0NLzsCTJ6GdypQ
5 - trades/viewtrade.php?id=96127121&userid=587322&signature=Av8W8u6peC8vjBg-a5nGbw

Help please

[Kekki25]

I'm very unsure about this trade. For me it seems very unfair to me!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96136436&userid=662332&signature=KUsXnd9JiZ3g0NROsX9LsA

[mitts]

I'm very unsure about this trade. For me it seems very unfair to me!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=96136436&userid=662332&signature=KUsXnd9JiZ3g0NROsX9LsA

yep, unfair to you. valuing rats at the lower end of c$ prices, theyd need to add 88c$ to make this fair.