The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[.crossfire.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63454185&userid=854868&signature=2B9_32sojETkf10mSFjrVg

I really don't know!

personally i would say its unfair. Rats don't have a very good demand, and the Cheshire goes for overpay from what Ive seen.

[Fwutter]

is this fair? Not good with bug amounts of c$

They'd be overpaying. Each of the grinners are worth 170-190 C$, so they'd be overpaying by about 20-40 C$.

Thank you ~ can I get another opinion

I agree. 400 c$ can get you a red rose pps, or a dark leopard at most. But even if the trade is unfair, once you're off the list, it's hard to get back on, especially with cs$.

[X X X]

Idk if this is fair on my side or theirs

[The Last Raven]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63454185&userid=854868&signature=2B9_32sojETkf10mSFjrVg

I really don't know!

personally i would say its unfair. Rats don't have a very good demand, and the Cheshire goes for overpay from what Ive seen.

I disagree. The Cheshire demand has lower a little and have been maxing out at a mid-high advent whereas this is a September list. No matter the sometimes lower demand of rats this is still major overpay because at the end of the day the Cheshire is still only worth an 09 rare.

But they may not accept if they prefer their pet to yours.

[.crossfire.]

Is this fair?

[Starlight~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63454185&userid=854868&signature=2B9_32sojETkf10mSFjrVg

I really don't know!

personally i would say its unfair. Rats don't have a very good demand, and the Cheshire goes for overpay from what Ive seen.

I disagree. The Cheshire demand has lower a little and have been maxing out at a mid-high advent whereas this is a September list. No matter the sometimes lower demand of rats this is still major overpay because at the end of the day the Cheshire is still only worth an 09 rare.

But they may not accept if they prefer their pet to yours.

Thank you so much! I really don't go by demand, but their list placement, so this really helps! Thank you so much!

[.crossfire.]

Idk if this is fair on my side or theirs

i believe they are overpaying. The Dark Leopard is tier 13 on the september list while the two pets on your side are tier 1 advents.

[✧ strawberry ✧]

Is this fair?

It's overpay on their side, the 2011 common dog would be fair

[✧ strawberry ✧]

Idk if this is fair on my side or theirs

i believe they are overpaying. The Dark Leopard is tier 13 on the september list while the two pets on your side are tier 1 advents.

That is only the light leopard, a tier 2 September list

Rarity wise, it's overpay on their side, but in my experience, the light Leopard is hard to trade off whereas the pets in your side are much easier to trade off

[세레비]

Idk if this is fair on my side or theirs

i believe they are overpaying. The Dark Leopard is tier 13 on the september list while the two pets on your side are tier 1 advents.

While that is correct, I'd like to point out that's a Light Leopard, not a Dark Leopard. This is what the Dark Leopard actually looks like.
But, yes. Rarity wise, they're massively overpaying for both pets. Not sure about demand wise as I haven't seen people trading for it in a while now.