The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Vampcifer]

Would this have been fair if I added more C$?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... O44F05qNkA

[Hauntednightmares]

[quote="Chocolatemintcake"]http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63452648&userid=867096&signature=Z9M32qSyTTs_RkC9SPcpZg

Is this fair? I really love the trade and the fact the July is true date. but I wanna see about demand difference.

[Rusticsmile67]

is this fair? Not good with bug amounts of c$

They'd be overpaying. Each of the grinners are worth 170-190 C$, so they'd be overpaying by about 20-40 C$.

Thank you ~ can I get another opinion

[DizzyGlitchez]

Should i accept this trade? (i edited it, but ignore that) If no, what me or they should add?
Thanks in advance!

[Fwutter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63452648&userid=867096&signature=Z9M32qSyTTs_RkC9SPcpZg

Is this fair? I really love the trade and the fact the July is true date. but I wanna see about demand difference.

I agree with everyone else that gave you advice. The july pps side is overpaying with the extra '09 since the july pps and coontail are on the same tier. Personally I think the coontail is easier to trade off though.

[DizzyGlitchez]

Should i accept this trade? (i edited it, but ignore that) If no, what me or they should add?
Thanks in advance!

[Fwutter]

Should i accept this trade? (i edited it, but ignore that) If no, what me or they should add?
Thanks in advance!

This is unfair to you. They would need to add 3 more '09 uncommons and remove the 2 2010 uncommons.

[Starlight~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... f10mSFjrVg

I really don't know!

[Rusticsmile67]

is this fair? Not good with bug amounts of c$

They'd be overpaying. Each of the grinners are worth 170-190 C$, so they'd be overpaying by about 20-40 C$.

Thank you ~ can I get another opinion

[intergalacticat]

Help, quickly! Thanks in advance!