The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice pg. 457]

[Quackers <3]

Is this fair? Educated advice, please.
Thanks in advance.

Unfair to you, take out the uncommon on your side

[The Great ME!]

Fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jyDOpGq_uQ

Unfair to the bottom.

Okay, thanks. By how much, would you guess?

[goreyboy]

Is this fair? Educated advice, please.
Thanks in advance.

Unfair to you, take out the uncommon on your side

Ok, thanks~

[Shiro Okami Kokoro]

Is this trade fair?

Unfair to you.

[Sockeyee]

Isn't this overpay for the person offering quantity? I thought it was... The person I was trading with told me otherwise...

well it depends on how much the owner wants to keep the pet ((I know A LOT of people who would do anything for that pet/never give it up)) but i would say its little bit over pay, maybe remove 1-2 pets that are rare ((and are a recent date, the oldest pets are the most to value in my opinion)) but keep the very rares... i'm not quite sure this one is a bit tricky, I would have to say try to get very rares/rare pets that are in the same date range((if you have any)). Otherwise i would wait until someone else responds to this trade

[~kittykat~]

Is this trade fair?

Unfair to you.

It's definitely unfair to you, your pet is from the advent list, while their pet is not.

[Shiro Okami Kokoro]

Fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jyDOpGq_uQ

Unfair to the bottom.

Okay, thanks. By how much, would you guess?

I believe it's unfair by about a Blue Rose and a mid advent. But get a second opinion on that.

[Sunshine1515]

Is this fair? If not, what should be added/taken awayThanks in advance!

[Shiro Okami Kokoro]

Isn't this overpay for the person offering quantity? I thought it was... The person I was trading with told me otherwise...

well it depends on how much the owner wants to keep the pet ((I know A LOT of people who would do anything for that pet/never give it up)) but i would say its little bit over pay, maybe remove 1-2 pets that are rare ((and are a recent date, the oldest pets are the most to value in my opinion)) but keep the very rares... i'm not quite sure this one is a bit tricky, I would have to say try to get very rares/rare pets that are in the same date range((if you have any)). Otherwise i would wait until someone else responds to this trade

This thread is not made for advice given on personal opinion, but based on rarity (although sometimes on demand also). Please do not give uneducated advice.

As for the trade, it looks about fair, although given some demand based on rats it could be a little unfair to the top. I don't believe it is overpay on the quantity side though.

[whitedane]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24920016&userid=79786&signature=1jrKcz1C1k2nAwPFAn84ew

Is this fair?? If not then what can I add or take away?