The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Jack Pattillo]

. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D2u7tWdEGQ

How is this trade? Thank you for any help!

[timothee]

Is this trade fair? Thanks!

and this one¿ :3

and LAST ONE I PROMISE this one!

WATTT ONE MORE!! dis one!

Thank you so much to everyone who will help/ has helped I know this is a lot!

[luc]

x- Is this fair? I know it's technically fair but from what I've seen it's incredibly hard to trade onto the rares list? Does the same thing go for C$?

[spacecatmint]

. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D2u7tWdEGQ

How is this trade? Thank you for any help!

your side is worth a high advent, so it only depends how much you value a punk dog at. I've usually seen them go for tier 7s, but demand is user based so it's up to you whether you want to pay this much or not c:

the punk dog is, by list, worth 5-6 09 rares though, so you would be overpaying.

[X X X]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DMI9Lf7t_w

Any help is appreciated ^^

[Jack Pattillo]

x- Is this fair? I know it's technically fair but from what I've seen it's incredibly hard to trade onto the rares list? Does the same thing go for C$?

I personally would not take it. The grinner is worth 130-150c$, so they are overpaying, however it is difficult to get back onto the rares list after trading your pets that way. So it's up to you whether or not you want the c$, but to me it isn't worth it.

[among us]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... i-Yg4uSqNw
got this bid for my black eyed galaxy auction not sure if it's under/fair or over demand wise I hope someone can help me have a lovely week everyone!

[Jack Pattillo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63447651&userid=817634&signature=PF-Q94Zr_fpqi-Yg4uSqNw
got this bid for my black eyed galaxy auction not sure if it's under/fair or over demand wise I hope someone can help me have a lovely week everyone!

All of those pets have very low demand. The only thing I personally like in that trade is the pocky item, but that alone is only worth an '09 rare

[Fwutter]

. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D2u7tWdEGQ

How is this trade? Thank you for any help!

The pets they've asked from you could get you a tier 8 advent list pet. So it's unfair to you rarity wise since that punk dog is only a tier 5. Demand wise, the punks usually do go for overpay since it is a store list pet, but since demand is user based, its up to you. Personally I wouldn't accept it because its unfair to you rarity wise.

[among us]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63447651&userid=817634&signature=PF-Q94Zr_fpqi-Yg4uSqNw
got this bid for my black eyed galaxy auction not sure if it's under/fair or over demand wise I hope someone can help me have a lovely week everyone!

All of those pets have very low demand. The only thing I personally like in that trade is the pocky item, but that alone is only worth an '09 rare

alright thank you so much! Any second opinions?