The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Ghostflake]

Help, thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99492575&userid=1022867&signature=VQIQ7QljdCAL_s6y0oylkw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99460680&userid=1022867&signature=j7hs98I5QDB_sC9q15eDAw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98790333&userid=1022867&signature=zwbPZP33HF1vihEyRqjyuA

I really need the answers

I really need the answers ASAP, please help

[holodog]

Is this fair? Thank you for any help!

[SolarSonnet]

Is this fair? Thank you for any help!

Rarity-wise? Yes. They're both 2009 VR Pets not on the list, worth the 3-month rule/2 09 rares. Demand-wise? I've gotten a lot more out of that Malk Wolf. Realistically you could expect to get 2 09 Rares out of the dog, but I've gotten 0.5-1 MA (Around 3-6 '09 Rares) out of that wolf before. Especially a true-date. I'd keep the wolf and expect 3-4 '09 rares or more out of it. Funnily enough, its littermate the Streaked-Fire Malk Wolf is on the October List, but it isn't, despite the fact that the streaked fire wolf typically goes for less than him for what I've seen due to demand reasons.

I'd get a second opinion, though.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99494528&userid=830020&signature=OBZBmte7DYxzR1ARk8xT6w
hello is this fair

Strawberry dog is a MA = 6-9 09 Rares, they're overpaying by a little on the high end of ~10 '09 rares
2 09s = 2 09s
14 10s = 7 09s
Store pets = If you value those stores at '10s each then they're 1.5 if you value them at '09s each then they're 3.
+Add of some earlier rares

You're at like 10.5 - 12 09 rare value for a pet that's worth 6-9 09 rares.

[AmandaPanda1234]

- trades/viewtrade.php?id=99492452&userid=746312&signature=T4nkSJ-p7zJQs57B9JNMew

How is this trade? I know the "rares list" has been discontinued but I know some people still use it as a guide for trading. Please feel free to message me or comment here! Thankyou

[swag]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99474633&userid=1016830&signature=Eb057pfxW8UMUWLajaSs0A
is this fair? thanks in advance

You’ve provided the wrong link. Look for the one available at the bottom of the trade, that allows you to share with others :)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99474633&userid=1016830&signature=Eb057pfxW8UMUWLajaSs0A here, seems to be the same link though

[Wilsa]

Hi,
Someone helps me? I don't know how to evaluate items trades

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99493844&userid=42478&signature=0smqt21V6ls5k-8l6mv0Pw

Thank you

[Glowbringer]

Hi,
Someone helps me? I don't know how to evaluate items trades

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99493844&userid=42478&signature=0smqt21V6ls5k-8l6mv0Pw

Thank you

Unfair to you. Im not sure about all the items but the cloud monkey alone is worth a 2016 uncommon and their side isnt even close to that.

[Wilsa]

Thank you

[abbie.]

hi! any advice on these two trades?
x
x
thank you in advance!!

[IvyCat8]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99497003
Hello! I sent this trade for a horse I've been looking for a while and I was wondering if my side is fair?? Thanks