The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[MerryEaster]

Ok, well i have an '08 very rare, released around christmas

People have been sending me, sorry to sound rude, but crappy offers for her. What would be the best offer? Currently, someone has a red rose dog and a cat for valentines day, released in '09

[Diabolic]

Green Toxic

for

2 Border Collies, 1 Black Advent, and 1 of this.

Unfair for tox.

I have an auction going and I need help figuring out which offer is best.

Please ignore the order the offers are curently in, and just tell me which offer would be most fair for the dog.

viewtopic.php?f=40&t=205304

UR Mint horse is the best offer by far.
Second best is offer nr. 5 , the one with the Joker.

I do think you could get more for a sunback though. The UR horses aren't very 'hot' trading fodder and thus not very valuable. Mint is consideralby more rare than the other one though.

[Seasonal]

Their side

My side
More of my side
Li'l bit more

Excluding the doubles, is this a fair trade? If not, how do I make it fair. C: (The doubles are accidents I put on when I sent the suggestion, and they sent the exact same thing back to me. Oo EDIT: Except the May lion that was on their side)

I still need some help with this. P: Thanks. C:

I think that it would be fair, depending on how you value Rats..

For



Since the striped dog only became rare recently, I'm unsure. What would be more fair?

Unfair to the Wood Dog.

[MerryEaster]

Another
Is it fair, to trade this group http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... pid=592893
for a yellow sorbet?

[Seasonal]

Another
Is it fair, to trade this group http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... pid=592893
for a yellow sorbet?

Very unfair to the Yellow Sorbet.

[SagittariusII]

How could I change this group to make it fair for a growing white July?

Hmm. . .I'm not very sure on this one, but I'll try!
It seems fair, but I don't know for sure. . .
The Green Sorbet bumps up to a good offer a lot.
I would have to say fair ^-^

Thank you. Are there any other opinions?

[Vell]

What is the best deal I could get for a ce galaxyin toxics(maybe other rare dogs to fill in the gaps)

[Endiriana]

would this be fair?

them:

me: + a few uncommon dogs from beginning of 2009 (I don't know how many)


and


how many rare rainbow draft ponies from August 2009 would be fair for this one:

(rare)

[calistaria]

My side: Green UR butterflywolf
Their side: Blue-eyed black advent, advent 08 heart PPS, Celesial PPS

My side: White Malk dragon
Their side: Very rare wolf PPS, Celestial PPS

[Kaliyana]

For

Rare '08
Rare '10
Rare '10
Rare '10
Rare '10
Rare '09
Rare '09

Fair?