The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[gothboyclique]

im sorry! i didnt know lol but is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=83945524&userid=868768&signature=Y08VwzI3b4brwQSmEmT1BQ

[nobxdy]

boop
I just got this trade, and was wondering what some of you think about it! I can't remember where the items are in the archives, so if someone could help me out that would be amazing. I AM searching for items, so please no "you shouldn't do this because they're items" responses. Thank you! ^^

can't remember where the other items are from off of the top of my head, but the blanket is an '11 christmas item and the fragile sticker is orignally from '12 at some point. valuing the blanket at an uncommon, i'd say that alone is worth both of your pets, but absolutely get a second opinion. c:

Thanks! Any second opinions before I decide? ^^
I would also like to know where the other items are in the archives that were not answered, thank you <3

[Fin72]

Is this fair? I’m not good with items trades/viewtrade.php?id=83934567&userid=774404&signature=fQX4KKrWdM8LW_0Gbjw5Tg

I also made this trade a really really long time ago a and I’m just curious if it was fair. trades/viewtrade.php?id=60161184&userid=774404&signature=pfhxg4qFkkrXolfwZcQ2OA

[LemonBunny]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83945365&userid=42650&signature=2cqnFOnfLZ5I-863cZZwjg

Would this be fair? The dog is a true date if that helps! Thank you so much for any help, it's greatly appreciated!

[Falco]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83944853&userid=841851&signature=ZmFL9f-fzigfJYHAn-Icog
Canceled this because I'm 99% sure they wanted me to over pay by a lot. Just the UR holy is a fair swap for he fox, am I wrong? Thanks!

[Jiloon]

Is this fair? I’m not good with items trades/viewtrade.php?id=83934567&userid=774404&signature=fQX4KKrWdM8LW_0Gbjw5Tg

I also made this trade a really really long time ago a and I’m just curious if it was fair. trades/viewtrade.php?id=60161184&userid=774404&signature=pfhxg4qFkkrXolfwZcQ2OA

Item trade is unfair to them, their side is worth at least 15C$. The pet trade is unfair to the Line Tribal because all pets in there are low demand, but the cake dog and Grinner do not add up to anywhere close to a even a Balloon, much less a Line Tribal (going off "retired ex-list")

[Spine]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83945365&userid=42650&signature=2cqnFOnfLZ5I-863cZZwjg

Would this be fair? The dog is a true date if that helps! Thank you so much for any help, it's greatly appreciated!

unfair to you

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83945365&userid=42650&signature=2cqnFOnfLZ5I-863cZZwjg

Would this be fair? The dog is a true date if that helps! Thank you so much for any help, it's greatly appreciated!

unfair to you

Please, if you're going to answer, explain your reasoning as stated in the rules of the thread. ^^
I agree it's unfair because the quantity side is only worth a 2016 rare.

[oceanoddity]

Hey there, could I have some help with this? Thanks so much to anyone who responds!!

I’m trying to consider the demand for the target dog as well as just fair by the rares list (even though it’s discontinued) with the two dogs :” )

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83945726&userid=647169&signature=ObJOhtI4UOfVfD2nT_lsnA

[Fin72]

Is this fair? I’m not good with items trades/viewtrade.php?id=83934567&userid=774404&signature=fQX4KKrWdM8LW_0Gbjw5Tg
I also made this trade a really really long time ago a and I’m just curious if it was fair. trades/viewtrade.php?id=60161184&userid=774404&signature=pfhxg4qFkkrXolfwZcQ2OA

Item trade is unfair to them, their side is worth at least 15C$. The pet trade is unfair to the Line Tribal because all pets in there are low demand, but the cake dog and Grinner do not add up to anywhere close to a even a Balloon, much less a Line Tribal (going off "retired ex-list")

[/quote]

Oh darn. Was it fair back in January of 2017? Sorry if I’m being annoying, I’m just curious