closed! go to new thread c:

[StarryWish.]

Hey guys is this a good trade? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3iOByKVFxQ
This is the trade with the best value I've gotten so far for my dogtag...

Good trade

Thanks! Second opinion?

That's a great trade! I would accept!#

[SonrienteMuerte]

Shima Trade #1
Shima Trade #2
Shima Trade #3
Shima Trade #4
Shima Trade #5

List Trade #1

I'm sorry there are so many. Thank you soooo much for your help!

[StarryWish.]

Is this fair? Thanks!

Yes it is!!

[StarryWish.]

Fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NrSaQuezzQ

[ThatPerson]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=60505905

Is this fair? I don't know how much 09 rares are worth or if this is worth the uncommon and the 16 rare.

Wrong link. Go to your trade. Click " share trade" and copy that link instead. [/quote]

Ahh, I've never done this before. I changed it though.

[.zombie]

how is this trade for my sunjewel? the person claims that sunjewels go for underpay. will gift informative answers, thank you.

[~Misty]

Is this fair? Thanks!

Yes it is!!

You need to give reasoning for your answer.
No, this is unfair to their side. A tier 1 advent is worth 3x 09 Rares. I believe they're overpaying. But, it is rare for people to trade off the list. So I would personally take it as for the overpay.

[Vulcriptic]

how is this trade for my sunjewel? the person claims that sunjewels go for underpay. will gift informative answers, thank you.

This is not fair for her/his side.

[StarryWish.]

Is this http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NrSaQuezzQ

[SonrienteMuerte]

Shima Trade #1
Shima Trade #2
Shima Trade #3
Shima Trade #4
Shima Trade #5

List Trade #1

I'm sorry there are so many. Thank you soooo much for your help!