The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Tif + Jo]

If I were you, I'd take the fair. I've been a member for a year and 8 months.

Just because you've been here longer does not make things fair/unfair. Granted, it does mean you may have more experience than newer members, but An unactive member from 08 out of the blue can say "Joker is fair for the Full Android Set" or the other way around.

I'd say it's unfair to the Cookie Advent. I've seen the An Android or two easily go for 09 Rares. The person on the Androids would have to add perhaps a couple 09 Rares, such as the Shima Ice/Dark PPS.

[Kaliyana]

and

For

and

I thought maybe because the second Horse is a Rare '08 that it might balance it out, but I just wanted to make sure.

Unfair to 08.08's are much more rarer than any other year.

...If I added 2 Android Dogs to the Lion and Eat Me, but kept my side the same would that be fair?

[Max Caulfield]

Them -

Me -

[huskynerd]

full android set
for
08 cookie advent + red grin?

Ok. Now I have one fair and one unfair. Any other opinions?

Unfair.

Them -

Me -

Wayyy unfair to you.

and

For

and

I thought maybe because the second Horse is a Rare '08 that it might balance it out, but I just wanted to make sure.

Unfair to 08.08's are much more rarer than any other year.

...If I added 2 Android Dogs to the Lion and Eat Me, but kept my side the same would that be fair?

That might be okay. The Eat Me is worth a good amount by now.

for...

I'd say unfair to the pps side- the pps is more rare than the pony or the cerebrus AND they're offering a 2008, and the King pup is one of the less common pups of the litter.

Yeah, I agree with you.

Side 1: Orange Light Stripe
Side 2: Rare candy cane bunny, UC Advent snow dog, rainbow Unicorn, 2 unicorns from June, and the light grey rat that used to be rare

If it's unfair, what should Side 2 add?

[Max Caulfield]

Ok, what should I add?

[huskynerd]

Ok, what should I add?

I'd say a Rare October would do it. ^^

[Max Caulfield]

Which one would be better?

[Neku]

for...

[Kaliyana]

for...

To me, that looks extremely unfair to the bottom group...
2 Rare Horses, and 8 Uncommons for 6 Uncommon Cats??
Nope nope, doesn't seem fair to me... Not at all...

[Neku]

for...

To me, that looks extremely unfair to the bottom group...
2 Rare Horses, and 8 Uncommons for 6 Uncommon Cats??
Nope nope, doesn't seem fair to me... Not at all...

Heh. And here I was thinking I might be under offering for the cats ^^; Warrior Cat rarities confuse me....If I took out the two rare horses, would that be fair-ish? I don't mind it being a bit unfair to me. ;d (I'm on bottom, btw)