The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[GoodbyeYall]

Hi!
Could I have some help with this trade please?
I had a look at the rare's list guide but would this be fair to both of us?

[HimikoToga]

Would this one be fair? Thanks for the help with my last trade!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CdkGAm9m4Q

[Kitkat2716]

any help is appreciated!

[dibidibidis]

Is this fair?
Link
I know the Basilisks have demand as they're list store pets, but I have close to zero experience with trading sitting cats so I'm not sure the extent of their demand. I've also been on a hiatus for a while, so a bit out of whack in general.

Thanks a bunch in advance!

[Odasakn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63438326&userid=797289&signature=jMIsrdDweyrI2jv566hA9A

?? Do I have to add and what should I add to make it fair?

[Zetirian]

Hi!
Could I have some help with this trade please?
I had a look at the rare's list guide but would this be fair to both of us?

Personally, I would say unfair to the Blood dog by about a '09 rare tops. But that doesn't factor in demand.

Would this one be fair? Thanks for the help with my last trade!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CdkGAm9m4Q

Completely fair!

any help is appreciated!

This is more up to you since the Bun doesn't have a set value. Check out recent bun auctions to see where it is going for demand wise. That would be your best bet to determine whether the trade is fair or not.

Is this fair?
Link
I know the Basilisks have demand as they're list store pets, but I have close to zero experience with trading sitting cats so I'm not sure the extent of their demand. I've also been on a hiatus for a while, so a bit out of whack in general.

Thanks a bunch in advance!

I answered this here, just in case you missed it.

Is this fair?
Link
I know the Basilisks have demand as they're list store pets, but I have close to zero experience with trading sitting cats so I'm not sure the extent of their demand. I've also been on a hiatus for a while, so a bit out of whack in general.

Thanks a bunch in advance!

I do know the sitting cats have demand because of their nature. People see them as 'warrior cats' which was their origin. With that said, rarity wise they are valued at 2-3 '09 rares for the vr's and the rare is a '09 rare. Taking it at pure face value, it's overpay on your side by at least a VR sitting cat and the rare sitting cat if you value them at the 3 '09 rare side of things. The '14 VR is worth an early '10 rare. Demand wise these pets can go for more than their value, all of them funny enough. Malks have demand and so do store pets.

With that said, ultimately the demand is up to you, if you want to see what the basilisk went for, it was only just pushed onto the rare's list.

I do recommend looking at auctions as well for all the pets. See what you think they are worth demand wise.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63438326&userid=797289&signature=jMIsrdDweyrI2jv566hA9A

?? Do I have too add and what should I add to make it fair?

Yes, you will need to add. I recon you would need to add 5-6 '09 rares for the trade to be fair.

[Odasakn]

Hi!
Could I have some help with this trade please?
I had a look at the rare's list guide but would this be fair to both of us?

Personally, I would say unfair to the Blood dog by about a '09 rare tops. But that doesn't factor in demand.

Would this one be fair? Thanks for the help with my last trade!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CdkGAm9m4Q

Completely fair!

any help is appreciated!

This is more up to you since the Bun doesn't have a set value. Check out recent bun auctions to see where it is going for demand wise. That would be your best bet to determine whether the trade is fair or not.

Is this fair?
Link
I know the Basilisks have demand as they're list store pets, but I have close to zero experience with trading sitting cats so I'm not sure the extent of their demand. I've also been on a hiatus for a while, so a bit out of whack in general.

Thanks a bunch in advance!

I answered this here, just in case you missed it.

Is this fair?
Link
I know the Basilisks have demand as they're list store pets, but I have close to zero experience with trading sitting cats so I'm not sure the extent of their demand. I've also been on a hiatus for a while, so a bit out of whack in general.

Thanks a bunch in advance!

I do know the sitting cats have demand because of their nature. People see them as 'warrior cats' which was their origin. With that said, rarity wise they are valued at 2-3 '09 rares for the vr's and the rare is a '09 rare. Taking it at pure face value, it's overpay on your side by at least a VR sitting cat and the rare sitting cat if you value them at the 3 '09 rare side of things. The '14 VR is worth an early '10 rare. Demand wise these pets can go for more than their value, all of them funny enough. Malks have demand and so do store pets.

With that said, ultimately the demand is up to you, if you want to see what the basilisk went for, it was only just pushed onto the rare's list.

I do recommend looking at auctions as well for all the pets. See what you think they are worth demand wise.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63438326&userid=797289&signature=jMIsrdDweyrI2jv566hA9A

?? Do I have too add and what should I add to make it fair?

Yes, you will need to add. I recon you would need to add 5-6 '09 rares for the trade to be fair.

Thank you. Second opinions??

[eboy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63437246&userid=654112&signature=YPu-QIC8-jN0jVK9QsUqEg
should i accept this

EDIT: i relink it because I want multiple answers to see if it is reliable.

[Kitkat2716]

@Pvrison

Thanks! However I should've mentioned I value it at a non so what would need to be fixed?
heres the trade again:)

[GoodbyeYall]

Hi!
Could I have some help with this trade please?
I had a look at the rare's list guide but would this be fair to both of us?

Personally, I would say unfair to the Blood dog by about a '09 rare tops. But that doesn't factor in demand.

Okay. Thank you very much!