The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ThunderCedar]

Can someone help me? Is this fair? thank you! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... g2GgKlUiJA

looks unfair to them, your pets are roughly fair for theirs taking rarity and dates into account, but their demon wings are from halloween 2013 and are overkill in this trade. Not to mention their pets cost tokens and yours are free adopts

[Sinbreaker]

would you say this is fair? I am stumped on their demand

Hey I'm on the other side of this, can we have an opinion? ^^

[Zacharie]

Hey, please help me w/ these three trades! Thanks a bunch to anyone who helps

1

2

3 - this one says they can add a spotted tribal as well.

I know they're all overpay, but given the raven's inflated demand I'm unsure of what to accept/edit.
Can I have a second opinion?

EDIT: also got this http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... M50AFnOKiw
And a trade offering a blue toxic for the raven- I'm on mobile currently and can't get both links, sorry!

[Eagle's Eye]

I'm offered this guy for my grey malk dragon. What does it usually go for? Has anyone had experience trading one away? Would you take this offer?

[Oshawott8888]

is this fair demand wise? what does the scarf on my side go for usually ^^?
And how about this ^^?

Could I get some more opinions ^^?

For the first trade, I believe you should take it as I've seen the store gryphons going for mid advents lately as their demand is rising steadily. The scarf item isn't that difficult to find or trade for so its overpay on their side, demand wise of course.

The second trade is unfair to the person offering the ur ice cat, demand and rarity wise. Even though the dark leopards demand is better in general, the ice cat tends to go for fair trades to slight underpay, so you would have to add a low mainlist to make it fair ^^
The rares and store pets don't make any difference at all, I believe that the other person just heard about the ice cats demand being bad, which in fact it isn't, but that's just my personal opinion ^^

okay, thank you so much ^^

[HimikoToga]

Is this fair? Please take Rarity and Demand into consideration. If it's unfair, what needs to be added/removed and to which side?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Jw4Qu_bdzQ

Is this fair as well? I don't usually do item trades.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RNFM5jAEMw

Is this somewhat fair considering demand? I know that I'm overpaying, but by how much?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MuSfZ79oTg

[onion]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 89iP-WsQKw

is this fair to my list cat? what would make it fair?

[Joof]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63110674&userid=350777&signature=FGtZaMRI34pz89iP-WsQKw

is this fair to my list cat? what would make it fair?

Quite unfair to them. The cat is worth 3-4 09 rares while their side adds up to 7 09 rares (:

[calculator]

fair? ty

[Sinbreaker]

fair? ty

Your overpaying an insane amount.
Patchworks have demand, but not "Main List" demand.