The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Fjord]

I got offered this and was wondering if it was fair to the other person. ^^;; Haven't played in a while - just wanted to make sure they don't get ripped off.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 85lYTjYp9A

In addition that one, I have this one as well:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4-UtdxsK0g

Both are unfair to you

Thanks! About what am I looking at to make them fair to me?

[Shiro Okami Kokoro]

How's this? (:

Unfair to you.

[Jean.]

How's this? (:

Unfair to you.

Thank you :3 What can be added or removed? ^^ She doesn't have alot of rares or any list pets.

[alliegator]

Is this trade fair for an animal egg? I've never been on for an Easter event, so I really don't know the worth of them. :s

Just one egg? Overpay

Thank you, I've been looking for an answer almost all day @-@;

[モグラ]

Okay, I really, really need help on this.

My auction ends today, and I've narrowed it down to these two:

Bid One

Bid Two

I am not asking for fairness based on only rarity. I also need help with the demand, what's more likely to help me out in the future. I don't know how valued fish are, or the lights dog, or that rare horse the second person offered.

I really, really need help from multiple people who are good/better than me with demand [hint hint; I'm not that good!]

Thank you all so much for your time, and I hope you all have a blessedly wonderful evening c:

[Bast]

What about this trade?? I'm not sure if their overpaying or if I am. Not very fond of Grinners though.

[Mizuki]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=25410375

I'm rubbish at trade values. Is this a good trade?

[Shiro Okami Kokoro]

How's this? (:

Unfair to you.

Thank you :3 What can be added or removed? ^^ She doesn't have alot of rares or any list pets.

Another '09 Rare to their side, maybe a little more.

Okay, I really, really need help on this.

My auction ends today, and I've narrowed it down to these two:

Bid One

Bid Two

I am not asking for fairness based on only rarity. I also need help with the demand, what's more likely to help me out in the future. I don't know how valued fish are, or the lights dog, or that rare horse the second person offered.

I really, really need help from multiple people who are good/better than me with demand [hint hint; I'm not that good!]

Thank you all so much for your time, and I hope you all have a blessedly wonderful evening c:

The first bid is the best, though the fish can be hard to trade off, the dog shouldn't be that hard to trade off. Though the store dog in the second bid would be easy to trade off, the difference in rarity makes the first bid better.

[Jean.]

Another '09 Rare to their side, maybe a little more.

Thank you! ^^ I'll see if they have one (:

[Shiro Okami Kokoro]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=25410375

I'm rubbish at trade values. Is this a good trade?

Wrong link.

What about this trade?? I'm not sure if their overpaying or if I am. Not very fond of Grinners though.

Technically, looks a little unfair to them. Though Grinners can be hard to trade off.