The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Taako]

I need help :c which bid would be better??? Demand wise and rarity was (mostly demand though)

111
222
333
444
555
666

Right now they are in no particular order c: please help!

333 is the best i think

[clarabow]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=18674423&userid=184302&signature=ZeKt7WyU3DY7Gha0_yOYzQ

Is this overpay, and if so, by how much? Thanks to anybody who helps <3

they don't need any other uncommon but the '09 one on their side.
they're overpaying

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=18674072&userid=209234&signature=GE4hjeWA3Rq5-TA_nIPBqw

Fair or unfair to me/them? Please help. ♥

fair swap I guess.
unless you could species, 'cause in that case your dog would be more popular.

[Caboose]

I need help :c which bid would be better??? Demand wise and rarity was (mostly demand though)

111
222
333
444
555
666

Right now they are in no particular order c: please help!

333 is the best i think

I probably agree, but 222 might still be tempting is it not? x3

[clarabow]

I need help :c which bid would be better??? Demand wise and rarity was (mostly demand though)

111
222
333
444
555
666

Right now they are in no particular order c: please help!

333 is the best i think

I probably agree, but 222 might still be tempting is it not? x3

both 222 and 333 are overpaying.
they are the best rarity-wise.
demand-wise, you're better off with 222.
rarity-wise, you're better off with 333.
hope that helps!

[A-train]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=18602522&userid=594&signature=GXV4s9iaoGqTrxjWLF5pew

Fair? ^_^

unfair to you.
they need to add a low advent and a high advent that would be
equal to the worth of the hyena.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=18602522&userid=594&signature=GXV4s9iaoGqTrxjWLF5pew

Fair? ^_^

Highly unfair to you. The Hyena and the Drink me dog is fair. The angel advent makes it beyond unfair.

not true at all.
the angel needs to be removed and an '09 rare should be added.
as well as another mid advent.
this is an alternate solution to the one I said above

Okay, so I should remove the angel and add an '09 rare + another mid advent to my side or their side?

[ātlas]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MZVxdx7K4Q

Is this fair? :3

[saorsa-]

Purple Batdog + Blue Grinner = Dark Pink Shima Butterfly Wolf?

Also... someone bid a UR Mint Horse for my 09 UR Dog. I know that the Mint Horse has very low demand, but it's such an overpay I was wondering if I should go ahead and auto it to them anyways. Opinions?

[Kristalli]

Thanks for the replies What should I add to make it fair? (the malk mutant for september 2009 green dog trade)
is this fair?: (second opinion)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LW0hGiClug

new: (urgent)
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ss9Q6YiQ_g

[clarabow]

Purple Batdog + Blue Grinner = Dark Pink Shima Butterfly Wolf?

Also... someone bid a UR Mint Horse for my 09 UR Dog. I know that the Mint Horse has very low demand, but it's such an overpay I was wondering if I should go ahead and auto it to them anyways. Opinions?

I would add three '09 rares to the side with the batdog.
otherwise it is fair

and I would auto that. Sure, its demand isn't the best, but you're still moving up
a lot and it's saving you the stress of getting up the lines in between.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=18620589&userid=76163&signature=-m79V5sNMY6BMZVxdx7K4Q

Is this fair? :3

unfair to them.
the mutant is only worth one early '09 rare

[A-train]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=18602522&userid=594&signature=GXV4s9iaoGqTrxjWLF5pew

Fair? ^_^

unfair to you.
they need to add a low advent and a high advent that would be
equal to the worth of the hyena.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=18602522&userid=594&signature=GXV4s9iaoGqTrxjWLF5pew

Fair? ^_^

Highly unfair to you. The Hyena and the Drink me dog is fair. The angel advent makes it beyond unfair.

not true at all.
the angel needs to be removed and an '09 rare should be added.
as well as another mid advent.
this is an alternate solution to the one I said above

Okay, so I should remove the angel and add an '09 rare + another mid advent to my side or their side?