The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[pigeon -]

would this be fair? c:
I value the Cheshire at a mid advent of that helps c:

[cloven]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73507147&userid=919435&signature=Yb_q19nqtbYbT_1sbQjQMg

Is this fair demand wise?

[ooo]

would this be fair? c:
I value the Cheshire at a mid advent of that helps c:

This is unfair to you both demand and rarity wise. The brown sleipnir is a mid septemer, their side adds up to a high advent (valuing the Cheshire as a mid advent).

[HALCYONDAZE]

Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73506565&userid=919360&signature=puiRQmTLPmbgk5FVP66rpg

I'm no expert but they are overpaying, that sitting cat is I think from 2009 and your Lion is a store pet. I would accept it.

[wolfie,]

Okay, so I was wondering if this trade is possibly fair? And yes, I do know that mine is two tiers higher, but like, does the true date of the Peppermint Eared Advent make it worth more? Thanks in advance (I might end up accepting either way since if being looking for a TD of this particular doggo :3)!! ^^

[kujoestar]

Would this be fair??

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73507188&userid=776776&signature=qf86rm2fT0wm14uiZTGqPQ
Thank you!

[wolfie,]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73507147&userid=919435&signature=Yb_q19nqtbYbT_1sbQjQMg

Is this fair demand wise?

This is absolutely unfair to you. I've seen the Raven Dog go from 1-2 nons recently, and I'm almost positive that their side doesn't even add up to a low main list (I may be wrong, but grinners have such bad demand honestly-). I wouldn't accept this if I were you.

[Silver Pandorica]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73507147&userid=919435&signature=Yb_q19nqtbYbT_1sbQjQMg

Is this fair demand wise?

I’d say no. The Raven is going for 1.5 nons right now, I believe (someone please correct me if I am wrong) and their side doesn’t even come close. You could get a lot more for it. I’d get a second opinion, though <3

Edit; Ah, ya beat me to it, Keeiiith :’) Better explanation above ^^’

[Guest]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73507147&userid=919435&signature=Yb_q19nqtbYbT_1sbQjQMg

Is this fair demand wise?

Rarity wise they are overpaying greatly. Demand varies from player to player so it's up to you to decide if that's enough for yours. I personally value the raven at a non and got one recently for that value. Some people might value it higher or lower, this is just how I personally value the pet

[Horror]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73507147&userid=919435&signature=Yb_q19nqtbYbT_1sbQjQMg

Is this fair demand wise?

This is absolutely unfair to you. I've seen the Raven Dog go from 1-2 nons recently, and I'm almost positive that their side doesn't even add up to a low main list (I may be wrong, but grinners have such bad demand honestly-). I wouldn't accept this if I were you.

Grinners don't have bad demand at all. That's just some rumor people keep spreading on this thread, it's very easy to trade them off fairly.
And the Raven doesn't always go for "1-2 nons". Recently I've seen it go for anywhere from a sorbet-blue toxic's value in lower list quantity to a straight non swap or non + little add for incentive. Though their side is worth a mid sept list and most people now only expect main lists anyways, but it's just up to you on what you're happy accepting.