The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[bookshelf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=66167380&userid=880031&signature=Tw9Xs8PgXHf2wzASU06Uvg

Is this fair?

id say fair if not over warrior cats have very high demand and the lost city lions have been going for 2010 rares currently becuz of demand lol

I'll have to disagree. You have to acknowledge the zodiac's demand as well, which in some cases trumps the cat's.
I'd say they have to add because I've seen uncommon warriors at the most going for an '09 rare, while I've seen zodiacs going for a couple of them.
and also I've never seen a lost city lion go for that much??

[karachi]

Am I being fair?

x

Edit: Also is this fair: x

[edd1e]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nJs7ikxt7A

Fair??

[Cedar]

is this trade fair?

i don't know if it's fair or not. thank you in advance.

personally i think they are under ^^

Is this fair? I'm very hesitant to trade, because,
It's a warrior cat
I want to auction it
They're horses

personally i think unfair the horses have low demand

Edit -
Also, what about this one? ( Take demand into consideration, please )

peronally i think its a little under demand wise its a good deal see if they will add

OH MY GOD ANOTHER TRADE -- please help, I need to know if any of these are fair demand wise. ;n;

i dont think its fair demand wise ^^

Please help, are any of the above fair? ( my favorite is the second )
I really need help.

Edit -
* sigh * again, is this fair?

nope under by quite alot

Which is under? All?

[Tea-]

please help!

[karachi]

is this fair??

Rarity wise no ;; don't know about demand wise ^^

please help!

Unfair to you, those sitting cats have good demand and the pets they are offering doesn't add up to the demand

[Daisy]

Am I being fair?

x

Edit: Also is this fair: x

Trade 1 : I looked into the demand of the joker and raven, and it looks like the joker is going for one non, and the raven is going for around a sorbet, sometimes a non.
Their side = 1 non + 2 sorbets |or| 2 nons + 1 sorbet.

On your side, the ur cat is worth 2 nons + 2 sorbets. So you are overpaying by a non or a sorbet depending on how you value the raven.

Trade 2: Unfair to you. They are offering a tier 3 mainlist for your tier 6 mainlist.

[karachi]

Am I being fair?

x

Edit: Also is this fair: x

Trade 1 : I looked into the demand of the joker and raven, and it looks like the joker is going for one non, and the raven is going for around a sorbet, sometimes a non.
Their side = 1 non + 2 sorbets |or| 2 nons + 1 sorbet.

On your side, the ur cat is worth 2 nons + 2 sorbets. So you are overpaying by a non or a sorbet depending on how you value the raven.

Trade 2: Unfair to you. They are offering a tier 3 mainlist for your tier 6 mainlist.

Alright, thank you! c:

[amaterasu_tea]

is this trade fair?

i don't know if it's fair or not. thank you in advance.

can i get a second opinion?

[Kaiiba]

Could I get some help with this trade? : )
I'm not really sure if its fair. : )
Thank you to anyone who helps! ♥

What about this one? ♥