The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[HimikoToga]

Is this fair? Please take Rarity and Demand into consideration. If it's unfair, what needs to be added/removed and to which side?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Jw4Qu_bdzQ

Is this fair as well? I don't usually do item trades.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RNFM5jAEMw

Is this somewhat fair considering demand? I know that I'm overpaying, but by how much?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MuSfZ79oTg

[HimikoToga]

Guys, I need help. ;__;
I am really not sure about this trade:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... v_HNTB6RhQ

I hope somebody can help me here,
thank you for any advice!

Fox

Unfair to you. The Dragon Store Pets are worth a late '10 Rare each, based on what I have been told on this thread. Get another opinion, though.

[ace.of.spades]

Fair yes or no?

Bloop

I don't think it is fair personally, because;
As the red rose pps is a main list and although they are offering the ur ice cat, the cheshire has very high demand which may even lead to be worth more than the ur ice cat. The two bunnies don't help the trade more balanced either.

A red rose pps is worth 11 mid advents. The ice cat is worth about just over 34. The bunnies are both mid advents. The cheshire can go for one with popularity. So unfair to the ice cat.

More opinions?

[LostForever]

Guys, I need help. ;__;
I am really not sure about this trade:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... v_HNTB6RhQ

I hope somebody can help me here,
thank you for any advice!

Fox

Unfair to you. The Dragon Store Pets are worth a late '10 Rare. Get another opinion, though.

I agree with DeanBean, that is only worth just over half of 1 of your dragons

[vapejuice]

This is a bid for my Rose PPS auction, is it fair? (Please incorporate demand)

Edit: Fixed link, sorry for breaking it in the first place!

Unfair to the rose pps, the pets you wanted can only get up to a high advent/low september list pet

Thanks! (Here come the questions- more opinions?)
What would need to be added?
How's the demand of all those store pets?
Do the lists on their side have any good or negative demand?

[LovelyRita]

is this fair? I really only want a little above 2 nons worth of pets for my dogtag since I want to trade it down but does this add up to a little above 2 nons?

[HimikoToga]

So I just got this trade... It looks kinda obscure if you ask me... xXx

Quite unfair to you. The 2008 Rare Dog is worth more than the 2009 Horse and 2016 Uncommon, bringing in rarity and species. Demand wise, I believe it's still unfair to you.

[Aethryn]

Is this fair, demand wise?

[HimikoToga]

Is this fair, demand wise?

From what I've seen, Scourge has a higher demand than most of the other warrior cats, including Hollyleaf, but excluding Brightheart, Jayfeather, and Yellowfang. Those three and Scourge seem to have equal demand.

[LovelyRita]

is this fair? I really only want a little above 2 nons worth of pets for my dogtag since I want to trade it down but does this add up to a little above 2 nons?