The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [rule about quoting!]

[Fantelle]

Is a BMD + Blue rose fair for a woodwing?

Unfair to woodwing, but do get a second opinion. :3

[Troi]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rNHDuNAs2g

[tazzazi]

Is a BMD + Blue rose fair for a woodwing?

Unfair to woodwing, but do get a second opinion. :3

Thanks!! Second opinion? What would need to be added?

[Koschei]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rNHDuNAs2g

Unfair to bottom. The White Febuary is quite in demand and an early 09 rare. The oldest pet on there is a late 10 uncommon

[Fat Unicorn]

Is a BMD + Blue rose fair for a woodwing?

Unfair to woodwing, but do get a second opinion. :3

Thanks!! Second opinion? What would need to be added?

Unfair to the Woodwing, the BMD should add 8 Mid Advents or a High September. :3

[Redwaller]

Is this trade fair, and if not, please offer a suggestion as to how to balance it. Thank you so much for your time.

[Fat Unicorn]

Is this trade fair, and if not, please offer a suggestion as to how to balance it. Thank you so much for your time.

Unfair to you, the wings are worth a early 2009 rare - so they should add a mid 09 rare. :3

[Spoopy Season]

Is the bottom overpaying?

[tazzazi]

quote="Fat Unicorn"]

Is a BMD + Blue rose fair for a woodwing?

Unfair to woodwing, but do get a second opinion. :3

Thanks!! Second opinion? What would need to be added?

Unfair to the Woodwing, the BMD should add 8 Mid Advents or a High September. :3[/quote]
Wow. So much!! Thanks heaps!!

[Fantelle]

Is the bottom overpaying?

very unfair to top, isn't that obvious?