The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[the]

May I have some help with this trade please? ^_^
I'm not too great with quantity trades. c: Thank you for any replies. <3

You're overpaying a lot. The dark pink shima is worth 11 mid advents, so your blue rose (7 mid advents) + scarf pps (3 mid advents) + grinner (2 mid advents + rare '09) alone are too much. All rares on your side make it even more overpay for the shima.

[Fixius]

Can someone please help me?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73497654&userid=238467&signature=EHbnq_II_6RggS2ct-A8zw

[osamu]

Second Opinions?

Help!!
and the trades start coming but they dont stop coming

[kujoestar]

— ignore —

[kujoestar]

Second Opinions?

I've been asking since yesterday. Help!!
I also don't want to keep them waiting. The first trade was sent to me 3 DAYS ago!!
and the trades start coming but they dont stop coming

The top rare in not sure about but the other one -

The top pet is only a tier 1 advent that is worth like 3-4 09 rares. Personally I would value your side as higher than that so I think it would be unfair to you!

[the]

Would this be fair??
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73497727&userid=776776&signature=KUvEo0Fm1hxGgrcYpm9byA
Thank you!

Your rat is worth 5 mid advents and their side is worth about 11, so very unfair to them.

[osamu]

]

Second Opinions?

I've been asking since yesterday. Help!!
I also don't want to keep them waiting. The first trade was sent to me 3 DAYS ago!!
and the trades start coming but they dont stop coming

The top rare in not sure about but the other one -

The top pet is only a tier 1 advent that is worth like 3-4 09 rares. Personally I would value your side as higher than that so I think it would be unfair to you!

I added one more 2009 rare, is it fair now?

[purple.]

@Greenpanthr

Trade 1:
Valuing every item at a common of the same year, their side would add up to 1 2011 common, 4 2012 commons, ~12 2013 commons, 8 2014 commons. Your side adds up to 27 2016 commons, 2 2017 commons, and 3 2018 commons
(If you do rarity math to decide that each common is worth an uncommon or 2 commons of the following year then it's unfair to them as their pets and items are older). You could also just decide what you value each item as and trade using that, as items don't have specific rarities, and have to be decided upon based on age and demand.

Trade 2:
In my opinion, I'd trade the wolf plush and Santa dress for the very rare (the wolf plush is worth a 2009 rare/very rare). If it was me, I'd probably ask for some commons and uncommons for my space items and such, but it really depends on how you value your items.

Trade 3:
I think that pet is an advent list (tier one). The socks are worth a late 09 rare/very rare, the plushie maybe a 2011 uncommon, the dragon isn't worth anything special, I'd probably trade it for a 2010 uncommon, and the collar and two last plushies are worth 2013 uncommons at most. Personally, I think that you are overpaying, but if you want list pets, that might be the way to go. It can sometimes be hard to find people wanting to trade off the list. Really, do whatever you'd like <3

Sorry for the long reply, hope I helped <3

[kujoestar]

Would this be fair? I’ve been told my cat is basically an 09 rare considering demand but I’m not sure about this.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73497747&userid=776776&signature=JZ6oJ-YZS9hW_3gLdHnoxg

[FOUND VERDICT]

Would this be fair? I’ve been told my cat is basically an 09 rare considering demand but I’m not sure about this.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73497747&userid=776776&signature=JZ6oJ-YZS9hW_3gLdHnoxg

it's usually only the sitting cats based on the "warrior cats" that have higher demand.
those go for fair trades, so they are overpaying with their early '09 rare alone