The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Vulturis]

is trading 100 misc pets for one of the new store rares fair?

[vinyl]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99335318&userid=124787&signature=UIaoBi5lP7Bvm41sc0a8sg

unsure about this one, any advice is appreciated!!

[♥HazelNightmare]

is trading 100 misc pets for one of the new store rares fair?

It’s hard to say unless we can see what pets they are . A new store pet is worth a 2011-2010 rare .

[zealouss]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99330421&userid=1002109&signature=7vWRij8K54wYvyOqV_VFkg

is this a fair trade? thank you so much in advance!

[vinyl]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99335318&userid=124787&signature=UIaoBi5lP7Bvm41sc0a8sg

unsure about this one, any advice is appreciated!!

[Vulturis]

is trading 100 misc pets for one of the new store rares fair?

It’s hard to say unless we can see what pets they are . A new store pet is worth a 2011-2010 rare .

Just miscellaneous bulk OMSC to uncommon.

[Puddles.]

Hey, is this a fair trade? I haven't been on in a while so I'm not too sure.

[Shakespeare]

Hey, is this a fair trade? I haven't been on in a while so I'm not too sure.

unfair to the corgis: each of the corgis go for at least 1 MA (if not more), and the very rare warrior cats also go for ~1 MA--so their 3 cats only cover 3 of the corgis (and again, sometimes the corgis fetch more.) [x][x]

is trading 100 misc pets for one of the new store rares fair?

It’s hard to say unless we can see what pets they are . A new store pet is worth a 2011-2010 rare .

Just miscellaneous bulk OMSC to uncommon.

really still just too hard to say without knowing the pets. 100 uncommon 2020 pets for example, using 2:1 math, is less than 1 2013 uncommon worth. 100 uncommon 2015 pets is like 3 2010 uncommons, so 1.5 rares, and technically worth a store pet. any mix of years later than that or anything less than uncommon will take you further from being fair.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99330421&userid=1002109&signature=7vWRij8K54wYvyOqV_VFkg

is this a fair trade? thank you so much in advance!

items are typically worth an uncommon of the same year, including the animal eggs other than 1-4. the first five items on their side (surfboard, tp, ornaments x5) are all 2012, whereas the eggs are all 2016--that alone is overpay. even if you want to value them a little less because they were just free event items, the difference in years would make up for it. while demand is of course always up to you and your trade partner, i think you can inarguably say that the animal eggs will have way more demand than random parts of sets like the ornaments, but the amount of overpay they're offering may make it worth it for you anyway--but yeah, technically it's overpay without even looking at the other items they're offering. the penguin is christmas '13, the cloak is christmas '21, and the rest is cs birthday/easter '22

[Barbatos]

Hello everyone,

I have received a trade where they are asking for a 2020 store pet for 29 chicken dollars and various 2021 pets, I have a feeling this isn't fair but i figured I would still ask. Thank you!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99333974&userid=944183&signature=YoYMo116xI9XycKqx5vemQ

[kamukoma]

Hello everyone,

I have received a trade where they are asking for a 2020 store pet for 29 chicken dollars and various 2021 pets, I have a feeling this isn't fair but i figured I would still ask. Thank you!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99333974&userid=944183&signature=YoYMo116xI9XycKqx5vemQ

2020 store pets, according to the forums ive looked at go for around 30-35 chicken dollars. ive seen that particular fennec with fairly high demand so lets say 35-40

40 chicken dollars - they already offered 29 in the trade, and the rest of the pets add up to ROUHGLY 4-5 (according to this thread Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3915876&hilit= ). so their total is around 34 chicken dollars.

if you value your store pet at around the mid range for the chicken dollars it can go for, then its fair. if youre looking for chicken dollars id accept, otherwise id reject it since you could probably push for a bit more going on the higher end of the pet's value scale i listed above

get a second opinion though! someone check my math lol its probably off