The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[VA BP]

Here's a section I took from The Rare's List
This is your dog
This is their dog

The September '08 List
(note that there is a gap in worth between these pets and the July/Augusts)
Dark Leopard = Orange Cerberus = Black Advent
Grey Dragon = Devil/Blood PPS = Blue Ice Rat
Blue Rose = Red-X = Angel Advent
Purple Batdog
Lime Ice Rat
Cake Dogs*** = White Dragon =Dark Pawprint Rat = Dark Heart Rat = Skull Rat
Flop-eared Pink September = Palomino Tess Horse
Red Rose = BMD = Sunjewel Bunny = Light Pawprint Rat = Light Heart Rat = Flower/Toxic Rat
Pink Striped September = Pink Patchy September = Winged Blood Dog
Scarf PPS
Target Dog
Light Leopard = Grinners = Halloween Cat = Skelebun
Red Dragon = Drink Me = Red Cerberus

* italics = not from September '08 but equivalent in value.
*** This does not include the Nick Cake Dog; it is on the advent list!

To try and fill in the gap, I suggested adding some September '08 pets. There is a full list right there.

okay thanks

[RestInPeace]

Fair?

I am not very good with demand, can somebody help me out?

Thank you c:

[Alaric Dixon <3]

Fair?

I am not very good with demand, can somebody help me out?

Thank you c:

I'd say that's fair. Currently the '09 Staff dogs are very popular, but I'm not sure about the '10, I havn't heard anything. As for the ponies, they are nothing special. The Malk pets are always favored, personally I think you could get a better deal if you tried, but in fairness, it is fair.

[Bad Habit]

is this trade fair?

help please?

[Takora Drakan]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... p4yLPj5t9g

Not sure about this, help is greatly apprechiated, you can also send me advice via PM.

[alasky]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=15148991&userid=219651&signature=tnn3X1R6Dd64ON4F5u616A
Is this fair?
Thank you^^!

[lkjhgfdsamnbvcxz]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=15148876&userid=1969&signature=KYHfNgdJ3EJup4yLPj5t9g

Not sure about this, help is greatly apprechiated, you can also send me advice via PM.

Unfair to you.

Fair?

I am not very good with demand, can somebody help me out?

Thank you c:

Unfair to them by a little, the Malk staff dog on their side would be enough.

[Narcisa]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IVcM8YIMkQ
Need help here asap D:

[AleraValerious]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=15149137&userid=46203&signature=noljWziiQEcCIVcM8YIMkQ
Need help here asap D:

Unfair to you : ) ( 2009 rare zebra side)

[.:Bazinga!:.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... duBPtHN_gA

Is this fair? :3 Thankyou to whoever helps!