The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[EchothroughDarkness]

Is this fair if not can you help me make it fair??
My sides the NonJewel

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70375803&userid=410864&signature=H2BniYT8ylFPPPXjSZjUBg

unfair to them. the non is worth 3 sorbets, the spotted tribal is worth two, so just the tribal and the sorb would be fair

Thankyou for that

[Galaxy Figs]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70375344&userid=106411&signature=ylBM3qvJGTarFAmHxKL0HA

Taking into account demand, how is this?

Edit: also what would need to be added for a Blue Toxic?

[Black Hole]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3oJNYVrBJw
???
I'm sorry if you can see that this has posted a lot on this page, Im trying to post it but nothing is showing up, so I'm very sorry if it actually is! Please let me know 0:

[zenzi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70375494&userid=735465&signature=rM2wegJsVK103oJNYVrBJw
???
I'm sorry if you can see that this has posted a lot on this page, Im trying to post it but nothing is showing up, so I'm very sorry if it actually is! Please let me know 0:

unfair to you. their pet is worth an early-mid '09 rare, so just any of the two store pets from your side and maybe an old uncommon would be fair

[xXPizzaCatPrincessXx]

fair for ur dog?

Include demand and if u would accept it or not

I'm on the other side and trying to help. Demand wise I think it's unfair to them, but rarity wise, I think it's unfair to me. Which is more important?? Thanks for any help!
fair for ur dog?

[~Forgotten Dreams~]

A bulk offer for my Malk Dragon! I really want to work this out, so specific advice is appreciated, as we're both bad at list values. Thanks!

if i'm correct, i see four mid-advents there (butterbun, border collie, blue flower, and kiss pps) and the dragon cat pps can fetch advent lists so you could count that as a fifth. and a malk dragon is worth about 8-9 mid-advents(demand not considered). since a mid-advent is worth 7-8 '09 rares, they would owe you another 24 '09 rares. (they might be there and i am just too lazy to count) this is not taking demand into consideration though so i would try and get a second opinion with demand in mind since i don't bother to keep up with demand spikes. hope this helps!

Thank you this is super helpful! Anyone else know about demand?

[The Last Raven]

i honestly can't remember if i've posted this or not but could someone tell me if this is fair or not? thank you!!

cliiick

Unfair to you. A 2017 store pet is worth a late 2010 rare not an early 2010 rare.

[~Forgotten Dreams~]

this is unfair, correct? hh the store pets are really tempting

trade here

Very unfair. Your pet is worth more than the two new store pets.

[Cherubic]

Super tempted but not entirely sure about this

[Dizzy socks]

I would really appreciate any advice - thank you!