The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Meoauniaea]

Would all this:

be fair for this one pet?

[GermanNarutoOpening]

[...]
Referring to this, your side was worth 3 ‘09 rares, 2 late and one early to be more specific c:
Their rat is only worth 2 of the 3.

Thank you so much, this helped a whole lot, I'll keep this in mind in the future.

[...] This trade was unfair to you, as I believe two store pets would be fair for the rat. The addition of a third store pet wasn't necessary, and a '15 rare wouldn't make it fair to you.

Forgive me if I assumed wrong as to why you referred them to the C$ worth thread, but the C$ worth of a pet cannot be used to determine a side's value. It would make things less complicated, but sadly values don't really work out like that. [/size][/center]

Thank you so much, same as above, now I finally understand everything. You being so detailed in your answer is a huge deal and I highly appreciate it. I wasn't aware of this and you assumed correctly.

-snip-
this depends actually on when this happened, until recently (jan 19), your side was only 2 09 rares worth

It happened one hour ago, it was really quick, and sadly I can't contact the user to set things straight.

[JJdiner]

It happened one hour ago, it was really quick, and sadly I can't contact the user to set things straight.

ooh then yeah in that case it was definite overpay on your side. its alright though i don't know if foeing a person actually reports them to the staff, but if the staff did look it over they would see you are clearly not trying to scam them. also trading unfairly isn't always a trying to cheat someone and wouldn't get you kicked out i don't think. im pretty sure they make sure its when you are actualyl trying to cheat them out of pets, and even then i think they just return the pets unless its quite often

Would all this:

be fair for this one pet?

the first image doesn't show?

[kxLJM]

wouldn't this be overpay on their part? i didn't think my dog had any special demand or was on any list but id just like to make sure.
thank you for any help 💙

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79213923&userid=342304&signature=68vidzVvYiY310guYnyLsg

[wrath of man.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216753&userid=919101&signature=aGrUVDeTdHkGMd7ddXW72A

help on this please

[wrath of man.]

wouldn't this be overpay on their part? i didn't think my dog had any special demand or was on any list but id just like to make sure.
thank you for any help 💙

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79213923&userid=342304&signature=68vidzVvYiY310guYnyLsg

they are overpaying.

[wrath of man.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216753&userid=919101&signature=aGrUVDeTdHkGMd7ddXW72A

help on this please

[Stranger Things]

Someone who is good with items


is THIS fair?

[bookshelf]

x - help on rating this? i'm very unsure as the rats are moving up and i believe the aussie is moving down? i know it's rarity wise unfair to them, i'm just concerned with the rats' demand, even if they are moving up ^^ i'd love some opinions!

[Meoauniaea]

Would all this:

be fair for this one pet?