The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[GermanNarutoOpening]

Heyho ,

thanks in advance to anyone who's willing to help me here, I appreciate it a whole lot. Long story short, I was foe'd over a trade which I declined because I was apparently not really fair in my reasoning for doing so, and I wonder if I truly did something wrong here that may warrant such an action. I want to learn from this experience and it would help me a whole lot if someone gave me advice.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216414&userid=707044&signature=r5wJNHsydMJa442VN0pBTA

After referring them to the "How much is this pet worth in C$?" thread, I concluded that this trade wasn't fair at all, to which the user in question seemingly agreed, though they argued that their offer wasn't nearly as unfair as I portrayed it to be, and that they were only off by a 2015 rare which they should have added to their side. Are they right? Did I miss something here? The user was very polite and I don't think they had any ill-intentions in mind.

[JJdiner]

Is This Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216446&userid=919360&signature=wE_DpCUNtBTAPazfNV01oQ

this is overpay on their side, technically by the 3 month rule, idk if the lion makes up for it

[emjayy]

Is This Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216446&userid=919360&signature=wE_DpCUNtBTAPazfNV01oQ

I'd personally accept as that rat went VR the same time as the pink patchy september and should have been placed on the list. I believe it's going to be discussed ^^

[Ciapek]

Is this fair. I accepted the trade, but I want to see if it was fair

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216732&userid=953327&signature=JbuGZ-kAOvwPAVtROEf16w

[madisong]

Heyho ,
-snip-
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216414&userid=707044&signature=r5wJNHsydMJa442VN0pBTA

‘19 store pet= late '10 rare
'18 store pet= mid '10 rare
'17 store pet= early '10 rare
'16 store pet= late '09 rare
'15 store pet= mid '09 rare
'14 store pet= early '09 rare
'13 store pet= two '09 rares
Referring to this, your side was worth 3 ‘09 rares, 2 late and one early to be more specific c:
Their rat is only worth 2 of the 3.

[JJdiner]

Heyho ,
-snip-
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216414&userid=707044&signature=r5wJNHsydMJa442VN0pBTA

‘19 store pet= late '10 rare
'18 store pet= mid '10 rare
'17 store pet= early '10 rare
'16 store pet= late '09 rare
'15 store pet= mid '09 rare
'14 store pet= early '09 rare
'13 store pet= two '09 rares
Referring to this, your side was worth 3 ‘09 rares, 2 late and one early to be more specific c:
Their rat is only worth 2 of the 3.

this depends actually on when this happened, until recently (jan 19), your side was only 2 09 rares worth

Is this fair. I accepted the trade, but I want to see if it was fair

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216732&userid=953327&signature=JbuGZ-kAOvwPAVtROEf16w

yes they overpaid as your side is only worth a 2019 rare, which doesn't exist yet, or 2 2018 UCs

[jinbad]

Heyho ,

thanks in advance to anyone who's willing to help me here, I appreciate it a whole lot. Long story short, I was foe'd over a trade which I declined because I was apparently not really fair in my reasoning for doing so, and I wonder if I truly did something wrong here that may warrant such an action. I want to learn from this experience and it would help me a whole lot if someone gave me advice.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216414&userid=707044&signature=r5wJNHsydMJa442VN0pBTA

After referring them to the "How much is this pet worth in C$?" thread, I concluded that this trade wasn't fair at all, to which the user in question seemingly agreed, though they argued that their offer wasn't nearly as unfair as I portrayed it to be, and that they were only off by a 2015 rare which they should have added to their side. Are they right? Did I miss something here? The user was very polite and I don't think they had any ill-intentions in mind.

This trade was unfair to you, as I believe two store pets would be fair for the rat. The addition of a third store pet wasn't necessary, and a '15 rare wouldn't make it fair to you.

Forgive me if I assumed wrong as to why you referred them to the C$ worth thread, but the C$ worth of a pet cannot be used to determine a side's value. It would make things less complicated, but sadly values don't really work out like that.

[Ciapek]

Is this fair, I dont know what the new store pets are worth

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216771&userid=953327&signature=GhOCrzlWmqjC1aVrrzvpyg

[Overhaul]

Is this fair for my corgi?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216516&userid=906035&signature=OYc17wLzE29MI9CCud26PA

[JJdiner]

Is this fair, I dont know what the new store pets are worth

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216771&userid=953327&signature=GhOCrzlWmqjC1aVrrzvpyg

‘19 store pet= late '10 rare
'18 store pet= mid '10 rare
'17 store pet= early '10 rare
'16 store pet= late '09 rare
'15 store pet= mid '09 rare
'14 store pet= early '09 rare
'13 store pet= two '09 rares

their side is worth 1 09 rare. unfair to you

Is this fair for my corgi?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79216516&userid=906035&signature=OYc17wLzE29MI9CCud26PA

your corgi is from 2013 (whether it counts as an extend release and is valued as 2014 idk, i personally wouldn't, but it might not be technical) 2013 = 2 09 rares, so just one of their pets would eb fair, and if you count the dog as 2014 then it should be 1 09 rare, in which they are overpaying by 3