The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Talvace]

I'm still waiting to see if they want to change the trade around at all (swap out pets and what not), but is this fair for the most part? I'm new to trading lists of any kind, let alone main lists.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78225176&userid=263202&signature=3LVONoUiWu9ayjhMlP_0uQ

[debbie.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248048&userid=9044&signature=3gZxAk9hFRO0gXulFsKFvA

??? how much are the robot store cats worth?
I thought they were only worth a mid 09 rare?

[Vexious]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248048&userid=9044&signature=3gZxAk9hFRO0gXulFsKFvA

??? how much are the robot store cats worth?
I thought they were only worth a mid 09 rare?

unfair to you, I believe your right.

[drown]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248282&userid=804583&signature=BU6C0X4FC_5w241etYhTGw
Would this be fair? Don't know what the growing pet is/worth

[Chico_Mistpool]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248431&userid=811231&signature=cbnA-8iU1RsxQPEeoOHPXw

What would I have to add/remove to make this fair for both of us?

[fallen;]

Between these two trades, which is the best option for trading my peas?

one
two

[WeirdWhiteStarDoggo]

I feel very conflicted about this trade, what are your opinions? (The Jester, lions, and PPS already traded though, so I might resend)

i wouldn't
mostly because trading down rares is never an easy thing
people don't often respect the dates of old uncommons
personally, i see old uncommons as about the same as a rare 4-5 years younger
so a '12 uncommon for a '16 rare or a '13 uncommon for a '17 rare
your two pets are '18 rares so personally if the trade doesn't include at least the worth of 2 '14 uncommons i think you're getting a bad deal
and considering that trade becomes mostly young commons without that '13 jester, i wouldn't

[Telemel]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248454&userid=907285&signature=O9JnKvDNBq6Vg-SgRu9Eqg

Is this fair? If not what do I need to add, thank you to who replies! <3

[hayzel]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248257&userid=747307&signature=ev1LFH0AcK9BQDN2ftPglA
been offered this, what do BEGs usually go for and do they have decent demand? thank you in advance

edit: i’ve been send this: trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248522&userid=747307&signature=esR3jOXllnXY_2ccYxiFyQ
which they said the BW is worth 3 nons. Is it hard to trade off and would you recommend i take it for my strawb?

[Vexious]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248454&userid=907285&signature=O9JnKvDNBq6Vg-SgRu9Eqg

Is this fair? If not what do I need to add, thank you to who replies! <3

unfair to the cat as it is going to be placed somewhere on the mainlist, and I believe I see one list on your side?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248257&userid=747307&signature=ev1LFH0AcK9BQDN2ftPglA
been offered this, what do BEGs usually go for and do they have decent demand? thank you in advance

I believe 1-1.5 nons.