The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Defying Gravity]

Yup. For the plushie-based rats from last month and the Coraline plush dog from May.

And the item ornaments we got for free?

[tricks]

Yea.

[loyalwolf06]

Two Questions:

Me: Green and Black store pet
Them: two elf bunnies, aztec lion, female fox (or vixen lion female, as they called it), and cupid horse

Me: all 3 new store dogs (the set for 50C$)
Them: 1 cocoon (growing, I don't know what butterfly wolf it's from...guess I could ask), 1 bug BW caterpillar (the off-white one with yellow stripes), 1 november 08 pink & green newborn, 1 rainbow maned foal

I have the C$ available to accept both, but are they fair to me?

[tricks]

Two Questions:

Me: Green and Black store pet
Them: two elf bunnies, aztec lion, female fox (or vixen lion female, as they called it), and cupid horse

Me: all 3 new store dogs (the set for 50C$)
Them: 1 cocoon (growing, I don't know what butterfly wolf it's from...guess I could ask), 1 bug BW caterpillar (the off-white one with yellow stripes), 1 november 08 pink & green newborn, 1 rainbow maned foal

I have the C$ available to accept both, but are they fair to me?

Both are pretty fair, maybe slightly unfair to the other person.

[Defying Gravity]

Two Questions:

Me: Green and Black store pet
Them: two elf bunnies, aztec lion, female fox (or vixen lion female, as they called it), and cupid horse

Me: all 3 new store dogs (the set for 50C$)
Them: 1 cocoon (growing, I don't know what butterfly wolf it's from...guess I could ask), 1 bug BW caterpillar (the off-white one with yellow stripes), 1 november 08 pink & green newborn, 1 rainbow maned foal

I have the C$ available to accept both, but are they fair to me?

I'd say the first one is unfair, the second one is probably fair or a little bit of an over offer if the rainbow maned foal turns into the Rainbow Horse

[LostHope]

Two Questions:

Me: Green and Black store pet
Them: two elf bunnies, aztec lion, female fox (or vixen lion female, as they called it), and cupid horse

Me: all 3 new store dogs (the set for 50C$)
Them: 1 cocoon (growing, I don't know what butterfly wolf it's from...guess I could ask), 1 bug BW caterpillar (the off-white one with yellow stripes), 1 november 08 pink & green newborn, 1 rainbow maned foal

I have the C$ available to accept both, but are they fair to me?

Both are pretty fair, maybe slightly unfair to the other person.

I think the white with orange striped may be a new unreleased butterfly wolf. I've never seen it before.

[Defying Gravity]

I'd say in terms of the ornaments - 1 ornament per 1 plushy rat

And the Coraline Dogs would probably be somewhere around 1 Coraline dog for like 3 ornaments.

[loyalwolf06]

Two Questions:

Me: Green and Black store pet
Them: two elf bunnies, aztec lion, female fox (or vixen lion female, as they called it), and cupid horse

Me: all 3 new store dogs (the set for 50C$)
Them: 1 cocoon (growing, I don't know what butterfly wolf it's from...guess I could ask), 1 bug BW caterpillar (the off-white one with yellow stripes), 1 november 08 pink & green newborn, 1 rainbow maned foal

I have the C$ available to accept both, but are they fair to me?

I'd say the first one is unfair, the second one is probably fair or a little bit of an over offer if the rainbow maned foal turns into the Rainbow Horse

I highly doubt the rainbow foal will become the rainbow horse. So even not knowing what the cocoon might be you think it's fair for all 3 pets? I thought I could get a rare for each maybe and I will probably only get one rare out of this bunch, if that.

[tricks]

Two Questions:

Me: Green and Black store pet
Them: two elf bunnies, aztec lion, female fox (or vixen lion female, as they called it), and cupid horse

Me: all 3 new store dogs (the set for 50C$)
Them: 1 cocoon (growing, I don't know what butterfly wolf it's from...guess I could ask), 1 bug BW caterpillar (the off-white one with yellow stripes), 1 november 08 pink & green newborn, 1 rainbow maned foal

I have the C$ available to accept both, but are they fair to me?

Both are pretty fair, maybe slightly unfair to the other person.

I think the white with orange striped may be a new unreleased butterfly wolf. I've never seen it before.

I think it is too. Super fair to Loyalwolf, very unfair to other peep.

[loyalwolf06]

Two Questions:

Me: Green and Black store pet
Them: two elf bunnies, aztec lion, female fox (or vixen lion female, as they called it), and cupid horse

Me: all 3 new store dogs (the set for 50C$)
Them: 1 cocoon (growing, I don't know what butterfly wolf it's from...guess I could ask), 1 bug BW caterpillar (the off-white one with yellow stripes), 1 november 08 pink & green newborn, 1 rainbow maned foal

I have the C$ available to accept both, but are they fair to me?

Both are pretty fair, maybe slightly unfair to the other person.

I think the white with orange striped may be a new unreleased butterfly wolf. I've never seen it before.

It's not, Mausoleum cleared it up. It becomes one of the bug butterfly wolves.

Edit: The only UR butterfly wolf is the pink and blueish caterpillar. There isn't a new one, it's the same UR from last year.