The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[appyrose]

hi, :] is this fair?

trade

they are overpaying, the pps is only one line above the punk dog

thanks for the help!

[Sonmi-451]

Need help with an auction bid. How does this look? Thank you!

I would like to know as well. Thank you very much for any help!

That's certainly unfair to the 09 rares.

Ok, thank you. Do you know what should be changed?

EDIT: Sorry to ask for so much help on here, but does anyone know if this is fair? If not, how can it be changed to make it fair? Again, thank you very much for any help!

[Mavric]

EDIT: Sorry to ask for so much help on here, but does anyone know if this is fair? If not, how can it be changed to make it fair? Again, thank you very much for any help!

I would say its fair, the nick cake dog is two lines below the Brown Border Collie so the two rares should make up for it I might tweak the cake dogs side a little bit though...

[whoopsydaizy]

Non jewel + growing white july = ???

Someone offered a non jewel and a growing white july for a plains zebra. Is this fair? Thanks in advanced~
I have a feeling it isn't, I just want to be on the safe side, though :).

[DesireeCollins]

How fair is this? thankyou for any responces <3

That looks very unfair to me but Im not an expert, looks like you will overpay alot!

I know that it is close but Im not sure who is getting the better end of the stick...

It doesnt look very close to me, it looks like they will walk away with the better end of the stick. Idk Im not an expert but I know that the two very rare 2008 pets are worth alot so...

[Mavric]

It doesnt look very close to me, it looks like they will walk away with the better end of the stick. Idk Im not an expert but I know that the two very rare 2008 pets are worth alot so...

yes but alot of my pets are advents or septemers, only one which has a low demand is on the main rares list where as theres is a halfway decent rares list pet. but I did do my raity mat and I am overpaying not by much but still DX

[Sonmi-451]

EDIT: Sorry to ask for so much help on here, but does anyone know if this is fair? If not, how can it be changed to make it fair? Again, thank you very much for any help!

I would say its fair, the nick cake dog is two lines below the Brown Border Collie so the two rares should make up for it I might tweak the cake dogs side a little bit though...

Ok, thank you. Could I perhaps get a second opinion?

[Eren Yeager]

EDIT: Sorry to ask for so much help on here, but does anyone know if this is fair? If not, how can it be changed to make it fair? Again, thank you very much for any help!

I would say its fair, the nick cake dog is two lines below the Brown Border Collie so the two rares should make up for it I might tweak the cake dogs side a little bit though...

Ok, thank you. Could I perhaps get a second opinion?

I agree with mavric ^^

[Flicka]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... s4KPRIc6vA

[Sen507]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=15403133&userid=9355&signature=cAMjRnpXLxJ2s4KPRIc6vA

Unfair to you in my opinion.