The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Dissolve]

Is this fair? Thanks!

i would say its fair

[Celeste Fay]

Is this fair? Thanks!

unfair to the bottom

[Inska]

Would this list here~

Yellow Sorbet (Main List)
Line Tribal (Main List)
Blue Balloon (Main List)
Angel Advent (September List)
BMD (September List)
Drink Me (September List)
Brown Sleipnir (Advent List)
Vixen (Advent List)
Evil PPS (Advent List)
Marionette Dog (Advent List)
White Feb (Non List)
Shima Longtail (Non List)

Be fair to ask for in return for a Non-Tag?

thank you for any help guys <3

So, right now, the offer is around UR Flower Pot level, if my calculations are right, which is two sorbets + a green toxic or equivalent.
So, unfair to the non-tag, but I'm not sure what'd they'd have to add from there. ^^;
I'd want to say somewhere along a balloon dog.. But I would get a second opinion on that. c:

Actually, their side is worth more like a sorbet + red tox-butterbun list-wise, which equals a BEG, so they'd need to add a CEG.
However, considering the quantity and the demand of some of the included pets, it's probably a red tox-sorbet or so.

And the gap between the Flowerpot and a non is a green toxic (:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mfkMMpULog


This fair?

extremely unfair to them, by at least an Non

Not quite a non - the WWA is more than the gap between the non and the UR Lion.

is was this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7z6Gy3P8yg

Very unfair to them.

Agreed, unfair to them. You could get something close to that though demand-wise.

Can someone help me with this trade?? What would need to be added or taken away from either side?

Looks unfair to you.

May someone please tell me what would need to be added? Thank you

A mid and a low advent.

Would someone please help me out, and tell me if the trades below are fair or not (and if they're not, WHY they aren't fair)?

1. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4DNODvKFrw
2. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... zAfiDVpOpA
3. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sZuOI1qJWg
4. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UGGh0hzC6w

1. Looks around fair, maybe a bit unfair to the '08.
2. Rarity-wise slightly unfair to you, demand-wise it's definitely unfair to you.
3. Unfair to them.
4. Slightly unfair to them.

[Revan]

Is this fair? Thanks!

unfair to the bottom

Thanks again. What should be removed from the bottom to make it fair?

[*~Vixen~*]

Would this list here~
Yellow Sorbet (Main List)
Line Tribal (Main List)
Blue Balloon (Main List)
Angel Advent (September List)
BMD (September List)
Drink Me (September List)
Brown Sleipnir (Advent List)
Vixen (Advent List)
Evil PPS (Advent List)
Marionette Dog (Advent List)
White Feb (Non List)
Shima Longtail (Non List)

Be fair to ask for in return for a Non-Tag?

thank you for any help guys <3

So, right now, the offer is around UR Flower Pot level, if my calculations are right, which is two sorbets + a green toxic or equivalent.
So, unfair to the non-tag, but I'm not sure what'd they'd have to add from there. ^^;
I'd want to say somewhere along a balloon dog.. But I would get a second opinion on that. c:

Actually, their side is worth more like a sorbet + red tox-butterbun list-wise, which equals a BEG, so they'd need to add a CEG.
However, considering the quantity and the demand of some of the included pets, it's probably a red tox-sorbet or so.

And the gap between the Flowerpot and a non is a green toxic (:

Ok, thank you both very much for the help <3

[PenguinQueen]

Is this fair? Thanks!

i would say its fair

Don't give false advise, this is unfair to the bottom
The gray mini Husky is worth 5 '09 rares
You would be overpaying

[Yatsan-kun]

Help me rank the bids, please?)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RxQ5HlXHcQ
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SN0h_FQo1g
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xahH8x_Iag
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tKF_fmD9Zg

Thanks in advance

[Dissolve]

Is this fair? Thanks!

i would say its fair

Don't give false advise, this is unfair to the bottom
The gray mini Husky is worth 5 '09 rares
You would be overpaying

Mostly of the pets In the bottom dont have good demand, thats why I said its fair,Im not saying that I KNOW its fair, demand wise I think its fair

[Shep.]

Is this fair? Thanks!

i would say its fair

Don't give false advise, this is unfair to the bottom
The gray mini Husky is worth 5 '09 rares
You would be overpaying

Mostly of the pets In the bottom dont have good demand, thats why I said its fair,Im not saying that I KNOW its fair, demand wise I think its fair

❄ still: even with the low demand they would still be overpaying just a bit I would say; you could take off a few pets

~ Shep ;;

[Yatsan-kun]

Help me rank the bids, please?)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RxQ5HlXHcQ
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SN0h_FQo1g
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xahH8x_Iag
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tKF_fmD9Zg

Thanks in advance

Not sure that anybody saw it