"The" Rares List Guide - Do not ask about new UR's!

[Diabolic]

You should take this over to the What Is This Item Worth? thread and suggest
a rare items list there. Because people there actually trade for these items,
and have somekind of knowledge about what they are going for in collector and
non-collecotr rates.

That wouldn't be helpful though... I'm interested in knowing how the items relate to pets, not how they relate to each other. An items list would only have how they relate to each other.

Have you ever even looked at that thread? That thread is there so people
can ask what a item is worth compared to pets.

Last time I checked, the first page contained certain rare items and their value
in pets so that people wouldn't have to ask anymore.

It is not a big deal to go over there and ask if they perhaps could extend the list.
Because this is a list for pets and their values compared to eachother. Not items.

[Memories]

The Pocky and Halo listed on the first post of that thread is hardly a "rarity list". Plus the thread in general isn't active...

Why you are against them being added to the rarity list, anyway? Its not like it affects you - you can just ignore the items on the list.

[BrightPink]

The Pocky and Halo listed on the first post of that thread is hardly a "rarity list". Plus the thread in general isn't active...

Why you are against them being added to the rarity list, anyway? Its not like it affects you - you can just ignore the items on the list.

It would be active if you posted your questions and list request there.

[Diabolic]

The Pocky and Halo listed on the first post of that thread is hardly a "rarity list". Plus the thread in general isn't active...

Why you are against them being added to the rarity list, anyway? Its not like it affects you - you can just ignore the items on the list.

Nope, it isn't a list. Yet. However it makes sense to expand on it there,
where people actually discuss items and their value. Not in a thread for discussion on
PETS and their value.

I already told you why I'm against this. In several posts. Go back and re-read them.
They make perfect sense and are written in very good english if I
may say it myself.

[Memories]

In several posts. Go back and re-read them.
They make perfect sense and are written in very good english if I
may say it myself.

No need to get rude. This is a debate, not an argument.

I'm not asking for your reasons as to why the items shouldn't be added - I'm asking why you as a person are against it. In what way does this affect you negatively that makes you argue against it?

[Animall]

Estee, Diabolic isnt being negative. Shes telling you to simply go back and read her posts.

[BrightPink]

In several posts. Go back and re-read them.
They make perfect sense and are written in very good english if I
may say it myself.

No need to get rude. This is a debate, not an argument.

I'm not asking for your reasons as to why the items shouldn't be added - I'm asking why you as a person are against it. In what way does this affect you negatively that makes you argue against it?

I don't see anything rude about that post.
Some CS-ians started to abuse this word.

I vote for no items.

[Memories]

The underlining and the bit about good english struck me as rude....

And I saw her reasons, now I want to know her motive. If I understand the motive, then I will understand the argument better.
I'm not just looking for her motive either - I'm looking for the motives of the people arguing against it in general to help me better understand where you're coming from.

[Jackdaw Lord]

Estee, Diabolic isnt being negative. Shes telling you to simply go back and read her posts.

She's being needlessly snarky and passive-agressive, which can be considered 'rude'.

Regardless, I see no problems with having items added onto the list. Yes, some people don't care about them at all, but there seem to be quite a few collectors around.

[odin]

Also, if we have to vote on this, my vote on the subject is No, No Items Added.[/center]

Mine, too, will be no items added. This guide is for pets.