The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nasa]

how is this?

[12th]

Hi there! I need some help with this trade.
I'm not sure about demand wise... I'd appreciate the help! <3

[skunkiii]

hi is this trade fair?

[blurry_cat1]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91519088&userid=994729&signature=7UM2jwyMke2aXPPuHQ1wRw This?
I want to know do i make fair offer for sorbet. Usually i dont make offers so completely idk

[Kyrova]

Hello!
I received this trade and I don't know if it's fair or not?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91510121&userid=403626&signature=2BgrWS4HgL8__p4_AiDufA

[kate,]

Are any of these fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91514793&userid=830519&signature=o834vdnwTh_mJyhiGYU2Zg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91516392&userid=830519&signature=T2SKW3f9j7_qKV3Wez-8SA

[Miang]

Hello! Is this a fair trade?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91519217&userid=631204&signature=HP8m3cNTuvwHJo588vmvxQ

Thank you so much for your help! 💙🦭

[_Korat_]

is this trade fair?

edit:
i canceled this trade thinking it was way unfair to me and i just wanna check im right in thinking that?

[bugbaby]

Hello!
I received this trade and I don't know if it's fair or not?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91510121&userid=403626&signature=2BgrWS4HgL8__p4_AiDufA

if you value the watermelon dog at a mid-advent, it's worth at least 200 c$ and therefore unfair, if you value it at a normal '08 vr though it's worth 75-85 c$. personally i think you can get a little more than what you are being offered regardless

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91519088&userid=994729&signature=7UM2jwyMke2aXPPuHQ1wRw This?
I want to know do i make fair offer for sorbet. Usually i dont make offers so completely idk

sorb is worth 5-7 ma's, the jackalope and rose pps combined are worth 4-5, plus the 5 09 rares puts your side at a solid 5 ma's. it's on the low end of fair, adding a little more is a safe bet

Hello! Is thi a fair trade?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91519217&userid=631204&signature=HP8m3cNTuvwHJo588vmvxQ

Thank you so much for your help! 💙🦭

unfair to you, the card dogs can get up to 3 '09 rares and the 2016 store pet is worth about an early '09 rare, everything else is either in the store/worth an uncommon from their year and doesn't bridge the gap

Are any of these fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91514793&userid=830519&signature=o834vdnwTh_mJyhiGYU2Zg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91516392&userid=830519&signature=T2SKW3f9j7_qKV3Wez-8SA

for the first trade, your side is worth 3.5-4 nons while the eat me dog is worth 4-5, it's pretty fair (raven goes for 2-2.5 nons, marionette goes for 1.5)
for the second one your side is 2.5 for the raven, 1.25 for the ba, and 1.5 for the strawberry, so 5.25 nons. the drink me goes for 5-6 but closer to 6 because it has better demand than the eat me, fair or slight over to your side

is this trade fair?

under to you as their side is worth about 3 09 rares while malk elemental cats can get 4-5 09 rares

hi is this trade fair?

the ur pineapple is worth 1 non while their side is worth 4 09 rares (don't know about demand for mime gupps) but anyways very unfair to you

[Corgi Fox <3]

Boop 1 :]
Boop 2 :]
Are these trades fair?
Thank you for the help, in advance! ^-^