The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[FOUND VERDICT]

This is a bid for an auction they rated it a 1 outta 10 is this trade unfair?(I believe it's fair since I value the Shima long tail at a high advent)

demandwise it's around fair, the shima usually goes for an mid advent.
but buns aren't always the most popular and can be a little hard to trade, maybe that's why the rated it so low?

[Dobyeu]

This is a bid for an auction they rated it a 1 outta 10 is this trade unfair?(I believe it's fair since I value the Shima long tail at a high advent)

demandwise it's around fair, the shima usually goes for an mid advent.
but buns aren't always the most popular and can be a little hard to trade, maybe that's why the rated it so low?

Thank you! Another opinion?

[Soundgarden]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73475649&userid=811281&signature=ETuraiZ4na3vT_c8Lstu-w

What demand does the blue rose have and what does it usually go for?

[sumatra.]

how does this look?

[ i value the sunback at around 6-7 nons due to its original date. ]

thanks in advance for any input!

seems rather unfair to them, especially considering the quantity of high demand pets.
i'm sure their side could easily fetch an ur tiger

of course it depends where you value the BAs and eat/drink me set but i counted around 8 nons worth on their side

I also counted roughly 7-8 nons, but agreed that it depends where you value the BAs, eat me/drink me, and also the liontail set

[kaplantai]

i would really like some help on this one:
boop
thanks in advance for any help

[kujoestar]

Hey! Not sure what to do with this, please help me!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73475694&userid=776776&signature=vXUgKU0p3ngNYLsVUhodXg

Thank you!

[Soundgarden]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73475649&userid=811281&signature=ETuraiZ4na3vT_c8Lstu-w

What demand does the blue rose have and what does it usually go for?

[FOUND VERDICT]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73475649&userid=811281&signature=ETuraiZ4na3vT_c8Lstu-w

What demand does the blue rose have and what does it usually go for?

i personally would go for it.
the blue rose is an high septemberlist and can fetch slight overpay from what i've seen, as rose dogs in general have great demand.

the highest i usually see the zodiac set go is an low/mid septemberlist

[nightmare eyes!]

I'm not too good with item trades and this is probably fine, but is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73475427&userid=882781&signature=FP5czQhtppMadRkIjCVthA

thank you!

edit: this too? trades/viewtrade.php?id=73475746&userid=882781&signature=A2yoRU6i0AGGBnSdpo5sMQ

[kujoestar]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73475697&userid=601226&signature=4GD0VyUUlYu7QUlhtcVdSg

Warning: Bulk Trade

Hmm I think it’s still unfair to the cats, they have super high demand and your quantity is good though! Maybe add some more older rares?
I hope that helps!

Also please people don’t jump down my throat again for talking about demand lmao