The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[bristopher]

Is this fair ? We’ve been trying to work this out for awhile now.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87805873&userid=946259&signature=v-HJ2hAGgYapVZt_EOrEZw

Please help! ^^’ <33 Thanks in advance!

[Destiny]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87848190&userid=120747&signature=tjR-c3nsF55nHlBIslcFGg
2009 Robot Dog for 2009 BumbleBee Butterfly Wolf both VR

Is this fair? Does one have a much higher demand?

[FriedApplePie]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87859641&userid=180216&signature=6zzBLXnQ5iZR8lCTQ9EmJg
Was this fair ?

Was the other person aware of what their pet was worth? That is insane overpay, I personally haven’t seen anyone give a patchwork for a PPS Dragon Cat. A patchwork can go for about 1-1.5 Nons

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87848190&userid=120747&signature=tjR-c3nsF55nHlBIslcFGg
2009 Robot Dog for 2009 BumbleBee Butterfly Wolf both VR

Is this fair? Does one have a much higher demand?

Technically the dog has higher demand. From my personal experience, it was difficult for me to achieve that specific dog so I would take it. Feel free to get another opinion though

[mae]

Is this fair?<3

[cherri ♥︎]

hey!
is this a fair bid in my auction?
thinking of autoing!
thanks xx

[hellotheworld]

hey!
is this a fair bid in my auction?
thinking of autoing!
thanks xx

The dragon cat pps indeed has high demand, however this fluctuates a lot, and is not stable. Personally, I think this offer is a very good one, the advents are true dates and especially the hyena has extremely good demand. I would personally take this, as of what I have seen, the dragon cat pps is not fetching what it used to in the past.

[cherri ♥︎]

hey!
is this a fair bid in my auction?
thinking of autoing!
thanks xx

The dragon cat pps indeed has high demand, however this fluctuates a lot, and is not stable. Personally, I think this offer is a very good one, the advents are true dates and especially the hyena has extremely good demand. I would personally take this, as of what I have seen, the dragon cat pps is not fetching what it used to in the past.

thankyou heaps!

[mae]

Is this fair?<3

[cherri ♥︎]

hey!
ahh ok so i got another bid which i love,
which is better?
bid 1
bid 2
thankyou sm! <3

[ahirked]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87859641&userid=180216&signature=6zzBLXnQ5iZR8lCTQ9EmJg
Was this fair ?

i know the dragoncat pps has insane demand but I still believe this is extremely unfair to the patchwork

agreed. dragoncat pps has been going for a mid sept - low main, and that's overpay in itself.
the patchwork has been going for 1-1.5 nons, which is again driven by demand. this trade was very unfair to the patchwork.

the demand data cloud is trying to ascertain how much people would actually pay for the dragoncat pps in a trade, and I highly recommend this thread because of its dedication to research and identifying issues with values of pets.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87867207&userid=675160&signature=hI5su38027npkQQZAw1tbw :// need help Thanks

highest value items:
- butterflies = 2011 uc/r ea.
- horsehair wigs (natural) = can go for low demand 2009 rare; or high demand 2011/2010 rare ea.
- rose & grass = 2011 uc ea.
- slanted eyes = low demand 2009 r to a great demand 2011 r.

all the other items are worth an uncommon or so from their release date.

the jackalope (2012 store) you offered is a t1 ex-advent, which is going for an MA or 8 2009 rares. in conjunction with the other pets and c$, this would have been extreme overpay on your part.
I'd recommend researching the item values on the item worth thread and cs guide to items to make sure you're not overpaying.

Is this fair?<3

fair, 2012 stores go for 250c$ ea. consistently (source)

is this fair?

the pointy zombie is worth 2 09 rares or 3-month rule, so owing to the fact that there is a 5-month difference between the dog and the vr 09 spider, I'd say the added 09 rare makes it fair.
get a second opinion tho jic