The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Demonking Urizen]

Heyo, should be an easy one.
Fair?
2 2010s but I just want to make sure. Thanks!

fair. both creamsicle and pumpkin bat are worth 3 '09 rares

[.kyungsoo]

this?

[Leylard]

thank youu!
this one too!

[Caslixe]

please help
here

[rileypillow]

I feel like this may be overpay on the other person’s side?
Would also like a second opinion on this trade
Thank you so much :)

[72027]

fair or not? not sure what the malk mutant is worth

unfair to them, the malk mutant is 1 MA (7-9 ‘09 rares) your side is 4 09 rares + an ‘11 rare

second opinions? i thought demand-wise my lions were worth more.

[saküra]

fair or not? not sure what the malk mutant is worth

unfair to them, the malk mutant is 1 MA (7-9 ‘09 rares) your side is 4 09 rares + an ‘11 rare

second opinions? i thought demand-wise my lions were worth more.

i’m responding again but staff pets are high demand right now as well as lions. they both have really good demand and even then your lions could maybe get 2 ‘09 rares depending on who you trade. 3•2= 6 ‘09 rares plus the 2 ‘10 dogs= 1 ‘09 rare so that’s be 7 ‘09 rares + ‘11 rare. so it’s up to you and your trade partner if you guys wanna do this trade. i’m assuming they value the lions higher

[Leylard]

thank youu!
this one too!

[soccerali9]

I feel like this may be overpay on the other person’s side?
Would also like a second opinion on this trade
Thank you so much

For the second trade: Dasher is worth 1 09 VR or 2 09 rares
Their side: pets are worth around 1 2010 rares, items are worth at most 1 2011 UC
pets: 1 2011 R, 1 2012 R, 3 late 2012 uncommons
items: 4 blankets (freebies), poppy meadow + poppies (3x) (2017 UC/C each), Lost city event items (13x) (2017 UC/C each), horse figurine, playful dog plush, flowers (x5), Arm socks, Leg socks (unknown so estimating at 2017 UC)

Total maximum value of their side is 1 2010 rare and 1 2011 UC, which is very unfair to you. Even if we rounded up to 2 2010 rares, that's unfair to you.

Please note: I couldn't find all the items so for the sake of my sanity I estimated them at a 2017 UC each. That said, in my calculating that the total items worth 1 2011 UC, I was generous to the value of the items. It should be a slight overestimate of the items worth, and they still do not make up the difference in value. I would not take the trade.

[Caslixe]

please help
here