The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[TransgenderTabby]

Trade in question
{I will say I'm more interested in the rat but, I'm just wondering if this is fair to me, with and without considering demand. I can't even remember what year the PPS is from so vjfhfjr}

.Holli.

I got you homie! The PPS is from May 2009.
archive/2009/May/Dog
While the rat is from February 2009!
archive/2009/February/Rat
The three month rule works here so I'd say the trade is fair!

[venti]

is this fair? i'm very picky on my green toxic

[poorturtle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92619265&userid=566020&signature=b9kNiVjwc1xg5HSA2E_ryg

please send help hahaha

[Stranger Things]

Would THIS be fair?

I know by rarity, it's technically not but the demand of the line tribal is pretty bad.

Also just wondering on this trade. Is it fair? I thought .5 of a non was more around 5 MA’s rather than 7? And also what is the demand wise fairness?

[SussyMangos]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92635976&userid=948896&signature=LZTrEr_A0FqnmXB8i4N5hw
?

[Bonsai]

Would THIS be fair?

I know by rarity, it's technically not but the demand of the line tribal is pretty bad.

well the line tribal is worth 0.25 non (3-4 MAs )

they are offering you
target dog - 2 MA
roadkill - 5-6 09 rares

this is an undertrade but the target dog is high demand and the line tribal and all the other tribals have terrible demand and its very very hard to trade them off ( it took me 6 months to get rid of my gearback), if you can i would see if you could get them to add another MAs worth to make this fair but its up to you it doesnt look like the tribals demand is going to go up anytime soon it seems to be declining as i got offered a gearback for 380 chicken dollars yesterday so their value seems to be dropping further.

[Bonsai]

Would THIS be fair?

I know by rarity, it's technically not but the demand of the line tribal is pretty bad.

Also just wondering on this trade. Is it fair? I thought .5 of a non was more around 5 MA’s rather than 7? And also what is the demand wise fairness?

0.5 non is 5-7 mas

on this one their side is
July PPS - 1 non (low demand )
UR bengal - 1 - 1.5 non
= maximum 2.5 non

your side is
target dog - 2 MA
light leopard -2 MA
dogtag - 2 non ( can also go for 1.5)
road kill- 5-6 09 rares
peppermint earned -1 MA
maximum- 2.5 non

this trade is really up to you yours is at a max value assuming the dog tag at 2 nons worth as thats what ive seen him trade for recently , although the leopard and targets demand is pretty good right now and the PPS on their side is a nightmare to trade off hes not very popular the bengal is a popular pet however c:

[poorturtle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92619265&userid=566020&signature=b9kNiVjwc1xg5HSA2E_ryg

please send help hahaha

[Zigzagoon]

Help please. Is there any particular demand for the rainbow dogs? Thanks!

Trade link

[SussyMangos]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92635976&userid=948896&signature=LZTrEr_A0FqnmXB8i4N5hw
?