The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Dancing.cinnamon~]

I'm thinking a yes?

Demand wise, how fair is this?
Boopdancing.cinnamon~

[myth;]

I'm sure I've answered both of you before. XD

Could I get help or opinions on the following trades?

CEG + Advent for Joker
True Date CEG for Joker

Which is best?

CEGs andJokers are typically valued at a non each, though true dates of both have been known to trade for 1.5-2 nons.
The TD CEG offer is best in my opinion, they are very desirable right now.

I'm thinking a yes?

Demand wise, how fair is this?
Boopdancing.cinnamon~

As far as I know, the rose isn't quite as rare as most 2011 items. Their items are from 2009 and are worth considerably more than the rose, which makes it unfair to them.

The rat and spider would be a fair swap, and the butterfly wolf is overpay for the shadow dog, which does go for overpay because of it's popularity. Depends on your preferences, but they are overpaying.

[Joof]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73157709&userid=224744&signature=uM6mPwrC0za9pMciueAXGg

how's this? I'm not sure about the demand of the grinners...

It's a fair swap, but sometimes grinners don't trade for their full worth, or so I've heard.

I would like to add that I've never had issues trading off grinners, and I've owned many. ^^ Them having low demand is a rumor spread on this thread for whatever reason.

I agree. I also owned a few and I always got their full value when trading them off (:

[kanata]

this?

according to the guide, it's fair, but i've also heard the c$ guide is very outdated as of late so i'm quite confused

[GreenteaLatte]

It's a fair swap, but sometimes grinners don't trade for their full worth, or so I've heard.

I would like to add that I've never had issues trading off grinners, and I've owned many. ^^ Them having low demand is a rumor spread on this thread for whatever reason.

I agree. I also owned a few and I always got their full value when trading them off (:

Thanks for the help. Too bad it got auto canceled lol.

[wolfie,]

Patchwork dog = ? (Demand wise)

[Zombilon]

Patchwork dog = ? (Demand wise)

Might take a look at this: Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3790990&p=118593925&hilit=+patchwork#p118593925
Demand is up to the users involved. ^^

[nightmare eyes!]

Am I under on the first and over on the second? Thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73152826&userid=882781&signature=xGfKBiFmew9llp5iMd_XoA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73151644&userid=882781&signature=utFQbIKlX7UPSO7Fn5fA3w

[FOUND VERDICT]

Could i get some opinions on this demandwise please?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73159642&userid=33449&signature=jc6l_saqpIHzSuVvTU8ZoA

thanks!

[Viozel]

Am I under on the first and over on the second? Thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73152826&userid=882781&signature=xGfKBiFmew9llp5iMd_XoA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73151644&userid=882781&signature=utFQbIKlX7UPSO7Fn5fA3w

Rarity wise, you're over on both of them by a lot. Demand wise, the BA usually trades for around 2 sorbs I believe? In which case you'd still be over on both of them.

The first trade: your side is worth about a nonballoon and a spotted tribal, maybe less depending how you value the spotted tribal. A spotted tribal is worth 2 sorbs, so if you value the BA at 2 sorbs and the spotted tribal at it's worth, this is overpay on your side.

The second trade: everything added equals about 1060 C$, which is more than enough for a non, plus a spotted tribal. Even if they don't want to trade off the list with C$, even if they don't like spotted tribals, this is big overpay on your side.

All of this depends on how you and your trading partner value the BA. If they value it at a non plus a sorb for example, you'd be under in the first trade, and only overpaying by a little in the second.
Hope this helped!