The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[.zombie]

I was the one who sent this trade, and I'm getting self-doubty and anxious about whether I did (or how badly I) blew this trade with my offer.
click here...

Any advice would be welcome, as I'm sorta... Not the best with the high end trade market stuff. ^^;;;

The '10 rare would be fair enought for their piano tile pup, but with demand, i would think not. id repleace the rare rat with a dog [or another in demand species] of the same year uwu

[guil]

Thank you two for the advice! I... Sorta lack any '10 rare dogs, so I suppose I should cancel to save my partner time then?

[♡Chocolate♡]

hows this? tysm!!

[Lady Kiba]

I hate demand but factoring it in would a malk smile (april '10) be fair to a zodiac dog (jan '10)

[justina valentine]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LMNr3TmzCQ
Should i accept this? c:
Also what about this ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D1R9ANMoiw
omg getting so many offers for my sorbet

[Frankina]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58950476&userid=769336&signature=JLrJGWMbDHKSLMNr3TmzCQ
Should i accept this? c:

The demand of the BMD is pretty high right now but your
sorbet seems a bit of a stretch. The BMD usually goes for a low main list or
balloon dog at most and demand fluctuates from time to time.
So I wouldn't accept this - the sorbet has pretty solid demand so I think you
could definitely get more for it.

Edit-
the second offer is perfectly fair as the UR Grapes are on the same tier
as the sorbet. but the grapes have lower demand and are generally harder
to trade off. unless you really want to grapes I wouldn't take this.

[justina valentine]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58950476&userid=769336&signature=JLrJGWMbDHKSLMNr3TmzCQ
Should i accept this? c:

The demand of the BMD is pretty high right now but your
sorbet seems a bit of a stretch. The BMD usually goes for a low main list or
balloon dog at most and demand fluctuates from time to time.
So I wouldn't accept this - the sorbet has pretty solid demand so I think you
could definitely get more for it.

Okay thanks!
Second opinion please, also i just put another trade up in my first post

[justina valentine]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58950476&userid=769336&signature=JLrJGWMbDHKSLMNr3TmzCQ
Should i accept this? c:

The demand of the BMD is pretty high right now but your
sorbet seems a bit of a stretch. The BMD usually goes for a low main list or
balloon dog at most and demand fluctuates from time to time.
So I wouldn't accept this - the sorbet has pretty solid demand so I think you
could definitely get more for it.

Edit-
the second offer is perfectly fair as the UR Grapes are on the same tier
as the sorbet. but the grapes have lower demand and are generally harder
to trade off. unless you really want to grapes I wouldn't take this.

Thanks for the edit
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Glc5oyOzBA
Just got this trade as well cc:

[Castiel Winchester]

How dos this look?
I got the banana at a bargain price from a user who decided they preferred the design if my pets over the banana's rarity, so I'm not worried about getting the highest possible value.
I'm kind of thinking around 1 nons worth would be sorta fair; is that correct?

With demand of the banana, yes. A non would be pretty fair. However, the pets offered for the banana do not equal a non. They need to add around a spotted tribal or purple toxic.

What about compared to a Blue toxic + UR Grapes? I feel like this trade is pretty close to that worth, and has better demand, generally.

[fischloughlin]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58950476&userid=769336&signature=JLrJGWMbDHKSLMNr3TmzCQ
Should i accept this? c:

The demand of the BMD is pretty high right now but your
sorbet seems a bit of a stretch. The BMD usually goes for a low main list or
balloon dog at most and demand fluctuates from time to time.
So I wouldn't accept this - the sorbet has pretty solid demand so I think you
could definitely get more for it.

Edit-
the second offer is perfectly fair as the UR Grapes are on the same tier
as the sorbet. but the grapes have lower demand and are generally harder
to trade off. unless you really want to grapes I wouldn't take this.

Thank you for that!^ what could be added to make up for the grape's demand? (Im the other side c:)