The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[.crossfire.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92082838&userid=1000928&signature=jQBzZceyIwOhruEZ3DH0-w

Also got this
(True date is September 2008)

(just for future reference, it is best to edit your previous post than to double post). but it is unfair to you by about two '09 rares (if they take off the dog instead) but it also depends on what you value more, spiders or rats. neither have the best demand unless you are looking for someone who collects them.

[Pom d'Apee]

hello c:
can anyone tell me if this trade is fair ?
if not what can i or they need to add ? '-'
thank you in advance !♥

[PastelCupid]

Howdy folks! Is this fair? Thanks in advanced!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92080174&userid=736952&signature=0tZnq5W1wa77mgvmIIRmsQ

[Aleigh]

UR smore for UR malk + a zodiac dog?
Also how is this one?

[Tanybrid]

Are either of these trades fair? Thanks for help!

boop1

boop2

[~~Leafdapple~~]

trades/viewtrade.phpid=92082780&userid=1000928&signature=KS4VxldrGsb6fFwcmyhk6Q

Is this fair?
(The lion's true date 2013; slumber party)

[This Is Halloween]

is this fair for their 2011 seahorse store pet?

[VNKP]

Would the demand of these items affect anything or are they all just worth uncommons from their year?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92076910&userid=985924&signature=pNhQV9noThaiCOvdbI9oYA

[ThunderCedar]

Would the demand of these items affect anything or are they all just worth uncommons from their year?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92076910&userid=985924&signature=pNhQV9noThaiCOvdbI9oYA

They are worth uncommons from their years.
It is unfair to you.
1 dragon plush alone would be fair for their side as they are from 2011.

[~~Leafdapple~~]

trades/viewtrade.phpid=92082780&userid=1000928&signature=KS4VxldrGsb6fFwcmyhk6Q

Is this fair?
(The lion's true date 2013; slumber party)