The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[hou5159]

is this trade fair demand wise and rarity wise?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... c-OVnti8AA

[Silverstar]

is this trade fair demand wise and rarity wise?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... c-OVnti8AA

unfair to you either way.
your advent is worth 7-8' 09 rares.

[세레비]

is this trade fair demand wise and rarity wise?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... c-OVnti8AA

The top doesn't add up to anything, both rarity wise and demand wise.
A Purple Heart Advent is worth 7-8 mixed '09 rares, and their side only adds up to two '10 rares. This is extremely unfair to the bottom (or, assumingly, you).

[RainWingThing]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63527460&userid=870724&signature=SGlf0QOnjlUDmwFw_Z18mQ
Is this fair demand wise

Unfair to the tree, it has much better demand than the dog

[Madziu]

Any help with this trade would be appreciated.

[Rain;;]

Any help with this trade would be appreciated.

correct me if im wrong, this is fair rarity wise, but in demand wise the lion can go for a list pet as i have seen before!

[Fwutter]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63526256&userid=781977&signature=1NyIUxFEqWZq9lm-jiZxwA
Is this fair? Please take demand into consideration

They would be overpaying. They have at least two list pets in that, maybe three

Second opinions please
Also there is only one list in the trade..

If you value warriors on your side at an '09 rare each, your side is worth a tier 10 advent list pet. The top is worth aproximately 13-14 '09 rares, which could get them a low September list pet. Saying this they're overpaying demand wise. If you value them at there rarity, you traded them 2 '09 rares with a remainder of 3 '09 UC. So either way, demand or rairty wise it's unfair to the top.

[evanmyers]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JohtdDseJw
Fair, over or under? Just so that I can know if I have anything that's comparable to the small pupperino

Also thanks to the people who pointed out that I used the wrong link last time

[The Last Raven]

Any help with this trade would be appreciated.

correct me if im wrong, this is fair rarity wise, but in demand wise the lion can go for a list pet as i have seen before!

I honestly don't see these going for list pets anymore. Please be careful making statements like this. It drives demand up and greed becomes worse.
This is big overpay. The lion is only worth a 2012 very rare with in 3 months or 2 rares of the same.

[NatchiriNeko]

Is this fair to me??